Cost-effectiveness of neonatal surgery: first greeted with scepticism, now increasingly accepted

Abstract

Mortality rates in neonatal surgery have dropped markedly, illustrating the enormous progress made. Yet, new questions have arisen. To mention one, health care budgets have tightened. It follows that the effects of medical interventions should be weighted against their costs. As evidence was particularly sparse, we set out to analyse cost-effectiveness of neonatal surgery. The purpose of this article is to summarise our findings and to review recent studies. Moreover, this article explains the relevance of cost-effectiveness analysis and explores how cost-effectiveness interacts with other determinants of health care priority setting. Our research revealed that treatments for two common diagnostic categories in neonatal surgery (congenital anorectal malformations and congenital diaphragmatic hernia) produce good cost-effectiveness. Other groups also published cost-effectiveness studies in the field of neonatal surgery, although their number is still small. Contemporaneously, the economic aspects of health care have captured the interest of policy makers. Importantly, this is not to say that there are no other factors playing a role in priority setting, foremost among which are ethical questions and arguments of equity. This article concludes that, according to present evidence, neonatal surgery yields good value for money and contributes to equity in health.

Interdisciplinary management of infantile short bowel syndrome: resource consumption, growth, and nutrition

“…Still, the findings by Longworth et al 5 $355,195. [31,32]. A growing interest in evidence-based and cost-effective medicine has emerged [33,34]. Society increasingly demands to provide insight into whether the effects of treatment are large enough to justify its costs.…”

Late vs early ostomy closure for necrotizing enterocolitis: analysis of adhesion formation, resource consumption, and costs

“…There is a growing interest concerning the cost-effectiveness in neonatal surgery in the last decades [33][34][35]. In the current era of cost containment, it is increasingly important to demonstrate whether treatments are cost-effective.…”

Neonatal Bioethical Perspectives: Practice Considerations

“…8,43,44 Challenging these arguments is that cost effectiveness has no standard definition, and cost utility (efficiency) data is not readily available, appearing biased in favor of neonatal intensive care. In neonatal intensive care, the priorities in health care needs are often topics that fuel distributive justice debates.…”