Cost of dengue outbreaks: literature review and country case studies

Abstract

BackgroundDengue disease surveillance and vector surveillance are presumed to detect dengue outbreaks at an early stage and to save – through early response activities – resources, and reduce the social and economic impact of outbreaks on individuals, health systems and economies. The aim of this study is to unveil evidence on the cost of dengue outbreaks.MethodsEconomic evidence on dengue outbreaks was gathered by conducting a literature review and collecting information on the costs of recent dengue outbreaks in 4 countries: Peru, Dominican Republic, Vietnam, and Indonesia. The literature review distinguished between costs of dengue illness including cost of dengue outbreaks, cost of interventions and cost-effectiveness of interventions.ResultsSeventeen publications on cost of dengue showed a large range of costs from 0.2 Million US$ in Venezuela to 135.2 Million US$ in Brazil. However, these figures were not standardized to make them comparable. Furthermore, dengue outbreak costs are calculated differently across the publications, and cost of dengue illness is used interchangeably with cost of dengue outbreaks. Only one paper from Australia analysed the resources saved through active dengue surveillance. Costs of vector control interventions have been reported in 4 studies, indicating that the costs of such interventions are lower than those of actual outbreaks. Nine papers focussed on the cost-effectiveness of dengue vaccines or dengue vector control; they do not provide any direct information on cost of dengue outbreaks, but their modelling methodologies could guide future research on cost-effectiveness of national surveillance systems.The country case studies – conducted in very different geographic and health system settings - unveiled rough estimates for 2011 outbreak costs of: 12 million US$ in Vietnam, 6.75 million US$ in Indonesia, 4.5 million US$ in Peru and 2.8 million US$ in Dominican Republic (all in 2012 US$). The proportions of the different cost components (vector control; surveillance; information, education and communication; direct medical and indirect costs), as percentage of total costs, differed across the respective countries. Resources used for dengue disease control and treatment were country specific.ConclusionsThe evidence so far collected further confirms the methodological challenges in this field: 1) to define technically dengue outbreaks (what do we measure?) and 2) to measure accurately the costs in prospective field studies (how do we measure?). Currently, consensus on the technical definition of an outbreak is sought through the International Research Consortium on Dengue Risk Assessment, Management and Surveillance (IDAMS). Best practice guidelines should be further developed, also to improve the quality and comparability of cost study findings. Modelling the costs of dengue outbreaks and validating these models through field studies should guide further research.

The Human CD8 + T Cell Responses Induced by a Live Attenuated Tetravalent Dengue Vaccine Are Directed against Highly Conserved Epitopes

“…Recent reports estimate the number of annual infections with any of the four DENV serotypes (DENV1 to -4) to be as high as 390 million, of which 96 million manifest as clinically significant diseases, including life-threatening conditions such as dengue hemorrhagic fever and dengue shock syndrome (1). This constitutes an increasing public health problem in tropical and subtropical regions and underscores the urgent need for a vaccine against DENV (2).…”

Representações sociais sobre a dengue: uma revisão integrativa

“…Aedes aegypti, cujo número de infecções tem aumentado em escala global, provocando impactos na economia de diversos países e constituindo um importante problema de saúde pública da atualidade (1)(2)(3)(4) . A infecção por um dos quatro sorotipos do vírus DENV(1-4), relacionados ao gênero flavivírus (3)(4) análise e síntese dos resultados; e 6) apresentação da revisão (10) .…”

“…A infecção por um dos quatro sorotipos do vírus DENV(1-4), relacionados ao gênero flavivírus (3)(4) análise e síntese dos resultados; e 6) apresentação da revisão (10) .…”

Tecnologías de la Información y la Comunicación (TICs) en la vigilancia, prevención y control del dengue

“…Los brotes de dengue en la región de las Américas han sido irregulares y con grandes variaciones durante los últimos años. Se ha estimado que el costo promedio de control en la región es de $2,1 billones (rango $1-4 billones); por ello, los países deben establecer redes de vigilancia activa y detección precoz 4 . De esta manera, el uso de Google Trends®, Twitter®, aplicaciones en teléfonos inteligentes, SMS (Short Message Service), telefonía fija, televisión y radio representan aplicaciones innovadoras de las TICs en enfermedades infecciosas como el dengue (Tabla 1).…”