Cost-utility analysis of a preventive home visit program for older adults in Germany

Abstract

BackgroundMost older adults want to live independently in a familiar environment instead of moving to a nursing home. Preventive home visits based on multidimensional geriatric assessment can be one strategy to support this preference and might additionally reduce health care costs, due to the avoidance of costly nursing home admissions. The purpose of this study was to analyse the cost-effectiveness of preventive home visits from a societal perspective in Germany.MethodsThis study is part of a multi-centre, non-blinded, randomised controlled trial aiming at the reduction of nursing home admissions. Participants were older than 80 years and living at home. Up to three home visits were conducted to identify self-care deficits and risk factors, to present recommendations and to implement solutions. The control group received usual care. A cost-utility analysis using quality-adjusted life years (QALY) based on the EQ-5D was performed. Resource utilization was assessed by means of the interview version of a patient questionnaire. A cost-effectiveness acceptability curve controlled for prognostic variables was constructed and a sensitivity analysis to control for the influence of the mode of QALY calculation was performed.Results278 individuals (intervention group: 133; control group: 145) were included in the analysis. During 18 months follow-up mean adjusted total cost (mean: +4,401 EUR; bootstrapped standard error: 3,019.61 EUR) and number of QALY (mean: 0.0061 QALY; bootstrapped standard error: 0.0388 QALY) were higher in the intervention group, but differences were not significant. For preventive home visits the probability of an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio <50,000 EUR per QALY was only 15%. The results were robust with respect to the mode of QALY calculation.ConclusionsThe evaluated preventive home visits programme is unlikely to be cost-effective.Trial registrationClinical Trials.gov Identifier: NCT00644826.

Preventive home visits to promote the health-related quality of life of home-dwelling older people: Baseline findings and feasibility of a randomized, controlled trial

“…They were slightly older and there were more married people in our sample but the background population includes also those frailest older people in institutional settings which explains the difference. Their mean age and distribution of genders are in line with previous studies on PHVs [7,8] and the general Finnish older population (75+ years old) [23,24]. Our participants' comorbidity index is slightly higher than in the general European population [25], and 15D HRQoL score is well in line with the general aged population [23].…”

“…home visit programmes were studied only in a few randomized controlled studies [7,8]. Thus, a comprehensive assessment and multiprofessional intervention applied to an unselected older population could be an important area that has not been studied enough.…”

Cost-Utility of Quadrivalent Versus Trivalent Influenza Vaccine in Germany, Using an Individual-Based Dynamic Transmission Model

“…As an estimate, we applied the €50,000 per QALY threshold that is commonly used in European and German economic evaluations [24, 25]. …”

Convergent validity of the interRAI-HC for societal costs estimates in comparison with the RUD Lite instrument in community dwelling older adults

“…The resource utilisation services included in this study are similar to other cost studies among older adults [32, 33]. Metzelthin et al calculated the cost of care utilisation over a 24 month period for 346 community dwelling frail older adults in the Netherlands [33].…”