Costs and benefits of climate-smart agriculture: The case of the Dry Corridor in Guatemala

Abstract

Central American countries, particularly Guatemala, are experiencing extreme climate events which are disproportionately affecting agriculture and subsequently rural livelihoods. Governments are taking action to address climatic threats, but they need tools to assess the impact of policies and interventions aiming to decrease the impacts of climate change on agriculture. This research, conducted with national policy makers and climate change and agriculture stakeholders in Guatemala, provides a comparative analysis of eight climate-smart agriculture (CSA) practices and technologies associated with the smallholder maize-beans production system in the Dry Corridor. The practices were identified as high-interest for investment by national stakeholders. CSA practices and technologies aim to improve food security, resilience, and low emissions development, where possible and appropriate. The paper assesses the cost-benefit profile of the introduction of CSA options into farm production systems. Indicators related to profitability and valuation of environmental and social externalities are used to assess options. Probabilistic cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is used to address field variability and high uncertainty around parameter values. All practices except one were profitable over their lifecycle, with some practices, expected to be ideal for drought prone areas, presenting a higher risk for adoption. The results were discussed with national stakeholders who established best-bet CSA investment portfolios. This paper argues that a thorough understanding of the costs and benefits of potential CSA options is needed to channel investments effectively and efficiently towards both short- and long-term interventions and should be coupled with broader assessment of tradeoffs between CSA outcomes. (Résumé d'auteur

Economic Modeling of Climate-Smart Agriculture in Iran

“…Climate-smart agriculture or climate-friendly agriculture (Żukowska et al, 2016) is introduced as a sustainable approach to promote adaptation-mitigation synergies (FAO, 2017c;Chandra et al, 2017) and minimize the negative impacts by integrating the concerns for food security (Arslan et al, 2017;Żukowska et al, 2016). Climate-smart agriculture, as defined and presented by FAO in 2010 (FAO, 2010;Żukowska et al, 2016), aims at sustainably increasing food security and incomes, adapting and building resilience to climate change, and reduce and or remove greenhouse gasses emission, where possible (FAO, 2017b; Chandra et al, 2016;FAO, 2017c;Sain et al, 2017). According to this definition, climate-smart agriculture has three dimensions i.e.…”

Maize‐field complexity and farming system influence insectivorous birds’ contribution to arthropod herbivore regulation

“…Specifically, structurally heterogeneous farms with on‐farm trees can attract more bird, whereas diversifying crops and cover types, and maintaining thicker hedgerows, will enhance bird and predatory arthropod diversity (Lichtenberg et al., ). By contrast, monocultures under conventional farming are susceptible to pest population build‐ups or invasions, due to reduced niches for species (Rusch et al., ; Sain et al., ). On‐farm trees are particularly important for attracting narrow‐ranging insectivorous birds, whose predation on crop herbivores can be more impactful due to their localized, intensive foraging habits.…”

“…Specifically, structurally heterogeneous farms with on-farm trees can attract more bird, whereas diversifying crops and cover types, and maintaining thicker hedgerows, will enhance bird and predatory arthropod diversity (Lichtenberg et al, 2017). By contrast, monocultures under conventional farming are susceptible to pest population build-ups or invasions, due to reduced niches for species (Rusch et al, 2016;Sain et al, 2017).…”

Agroforestry systems provide firewood for livelihood improvement in Guatemala

“…In Guatemala, a dry corridor is "a semi-arid territory characterized by prolonged droughts, a broken topography consisting of hills and mountains, shallow soils with medium to low fertility rates and a tendency for erosion" (PNUD, 2013). The Dry Corridor experienced severe drought in the past decades for which the government of Guatemala provided emergency food aid and promoted the adaptation through agricultural practices that would mitigate the impact of drought, particularly to the most food insecure families (Sain et al, 2017). Several reports of Climate Change and its effect indicate that the rural area of the dry corridor will be most affected by droughts consequently families could be exposed to crops losses and lack of food and water (Castellanos and Guerra, 2009;Gutiérrez and Espinoza, 2010;Bouroncle et al, 2015;United Nations, 2018).…”