Costs and benefits of mandatory audit firm rotation: initial engagement experience of audit committee chairs and engagement partners

Abstract

Audit regulators remain divided on whether the costs of mandatory audit firm rotation (MAFR) will be outweighed by the benefits of the regulation. Existing research provides mixed results in support of the benefits of MAFR. This paper aims to complement these studies by examining what costs and benefits are experienced during the initial engagement after a MAFR. Interviews were conducted with dyads of South African audit committee chairs and audit partners involved in the same appointment process and initial audit engagement following a MAFR. While many audit committee chairs remained opposed to MAFR, most were impressed by the better-thanexpected benefits of the fresh perspective and challenge offered by a newly appointed audit firm, and the less than expected costs of losing the incumbent auditor's knowledge. By comparison, most audit partners expressed support for MAFR after their experience with the regulation and believed the policy would improve public perceptions of independence but raised concerns about the significant start-up costs their firms had been forced to absorb. As a result, while the findings suggest that the primary arguments against MAFR may be overstated, there is a risk that MAFR may compromise auditor independence by pressurising auditors to appease their new clients to retain the engagement and recover these initial costs. This paper provides insights for policymakers considering the costs and benefits of implementing MAFR, and for audit committees and auditors who seek to maximise the benefits while minimizing the costs of their next MAFR event.

Audit regulation and its relevance for audit quality in Namibia

“…(IESBA 2021, p. 32) Auditors' independence contributes to achieving trust in the audit profession (Power 2003). Regulators have introduced measures, inter alia mandatory rotation of audit firms, in an attempt to strengthen the independence of auditors (Harber 2018).…”

“…These scandals have led to serious concerns being raised about auditor independence and audit quality in general (Firth, Rui & Wu 2012). The quality of the audit function, as a means to prevent or detect corporate fraud, is being questioned by users of financial statements (Harber 2018).…”

Effect of Audit Quality on Value Relevance of Accounting Earnings of Manufacturing Companies Listed in Nigerian Exchange Group

“…The faithful representation of accounting earnings is in doubt and the failure of auditing to effectively and efficiently curtail management earnings machinations [10]. Thus, the reported income by some entities is questionable and its relationship with the audit process is given the pockets of corporate failures [5].…”

“…The effect of EPS and BVPS on share prices on one hand, and the auditor's role in providing reliable accounting earnings is gaining the interest of many scholars [13,5,10,14]. The most recent issue confronting the auditing profession-"Big Four auditor's work for SVB, Signature, and First Republic comes under scrutiny in aftermath of their collapses".…”