Counteracting learned non-use in chronic stroke patients with reinforcement-induced movement therapy

Abstract

BackgroundAfter stroke, patients who suffer from hemiparesis tend to suppress the use of the affected extremity, a condition called learned non-use. Consequently, the lack of training may lead to the progressive deterioration of motor function. Although Constraint-Induced Movement Therapies (CIMT) have shown to be effective in treating this condition, the method presents several limitations, and the high intensity of its protocols severely compromises its adherence. We propose a novel rehabilitation approach called Reinforcement-Induced Movement Therapy (RIMT), which proposes to restore motor function through maximizing arm use. This is achieved by exposing the patient to amplified goal-oriented movements in VR that match the intended actions of the patient. We hypothesize that through this method we can increase the patients self-efficacy, reverse learned non-use, and induce long-term motor improvements.MethodsWe conducted a randomized, double-blind, longitudinal clinical study with 18 chronic stroke patients. Patients performed 30 minutes of daily VR-based training during six weeks. During training, the experimental group experienced goal-oriented movement amplification in VR. The control group followed the same training protocol but without movement amplification. Evaluators blinded to group designation performed clinical measurements at the beginning, at the end of the training and at 12-weeks follow-up. We used the Fugl-Meyer Assessment for the upper extremities (UE-FM) (Sanford et al., Phys Ther 73:447–454, 1993) as a primary outcome measurement of motor recovery. Secondary outcome measurements included the Chedoke Arm and Hand Activity Inventory (CAHAI-7) (Barreca et al., Arch Phys Med Rehabil 6:1616–1622, 2005) for measuring functional motor gains in the performance of Activities of Daily Living (ADLs), the Barthel Index (BI) for the evaluation of the patient’s perceived independence (Collin et al., Int Disabil Stud 10:61–63, 1988), and the Hamilton scale (Knesevich et al., Br J Psychiatr J Mental Sci 131:49–52, 1977) for the identification of improvements in mood disorders that could be induced by the reinforcement-based intervention. In order to study and predict the effects of this intervention we implemented a computational model of recovery after stroke.ResultsWhile both groups showed significant motor gains at 6-weeks post-treatment, only the experimental group continued to exhibit further gains in UE-FM at 12-weeks follow-up (p<.05). This improvement was accompanied by a significant increase in arm-use during training in the experimental group.ConclusionsImplicitly reinforcing arm-use by augmenting visuomotor feedback as proposed by RIMT seems beneficial for inducing significant improvement in chronic stroke patients. By challenging the patients’ self-limiting believe system and perceived low self-efficacy this approach might counteract learned non-use.Trial registrationClinical Trials NCT02657070.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12984-016-0178-x) co...

Principles of Neurorehabilitation After Stroke Based on Motor Learning and Brain Plasticity Mechanisms

“…Although shaping appears to be one of the essential components of CIMT, its particular effect on motor recovery has not been studied on its own (Kwakkel et al, 2015). Increasing difficulty has been successfully used in standard care studies (Woldag et al, 2010), robot-assisted therapy (Lucca, 2009), and VR-based systems (Cameirão et al, 2012;Ballester Rubio et al, 2016), all of which showed beneficial effects on motor recovery. Task difficulty appears to be implicitly present in many tasks that investigate motor learning without being explicitly operationalized.…”

Revealing an extended critical window of recovery post-stroke

“…This work builds on previous research conducted with the RGS, a VR-based tool that promotes functional recovery post-stroke through goal-oriented embodied sensorimotor stimulation. A number of studies suggest the effectivity of RGS protocols for overcoming upper limb motor deficits (Cameirão et al, 2012 da Silva Cameirão et al, 2011; Ballester et al, 2016, 2015, 2017). These protocols rest on principles that are derived from the Distributed Adaptive Control theory of mind and brain (Verschure, 2012), which places recovery in the context of the acquisition and expression of goal-oriented voluntary behavior driven by perception, memory, value and goals and the optimization of perceptual and behavioral prediction.…”

Verbesserung motorischen Lernens in der Neurorehabilitation

“…Verstärkte Rückmeldung durch virtuelle Realitäten (um eine erhöhte Genauigkeit und den Bewegungsumfang zielgerichteter Bewegungen zu reflektieren) führte in einer anderen Studie bei chronisch von Schlaganfall betroffenen Patienten zu einem Anstieg motorischer Leistungen (Fugl-Meyer Assessment of the Upper Extremity). Ebenfalls verbesserte sich so der Armgebrauch im Vergleich zu einer Kontrollgruppe ohne diese erfolgsorientierte Rückmeldung [1].…”