Coup d’état and a democratic signal: The connection between protests and coups after the Cold War

Abstract

What connection exists between protests and coup attempts? Although recent studies have revealed that the former incites the latter, they generally do not consider international factors. We contend that post-Cold War nonviolent protests have promoted coup attempts. With sentiment in the international community turning against coups following the end of the Cold War, coup organizers have had to portray their actions as democratic. Launching a coup attempt during ongoing nonviolent protests became a convincing method to prove democratic bona fides. This is because the international community favors nonviolence, and it signals that the emerging regime will not have extreme preferences and will keep order. Conversely, the international community does not regard violent protests as legitimate, and staging a coup attempt during violent protests will not enable a military to claim legitimacy. This argument is tested through statistical analysis and by using the 2011 Egyptian coup as a case study. As expected, the results indicate that the impact of protests on coup attempts varies depending on (1) whether those protests are violent or nonviolent, and on (2) the period. Specifically, only the nonviolent protests in the post-Cold War era prompt coup attempts meaningfully.

Clouds with silver linings: how mobilization shapes the impact of coups on democratization

“…Both forces were present in Egypt in 2011, when the army removed President Mobarak following a popular uprising. A number of empirical studies confirm that coups are more likely during popular mobilization (Casper and Tyson, 2014;Frantz and Ezrow, 2011;Johnson and Thyne, 2018;Powell, 2012;Wig and Rød, 2016;Yukawa et al, 2022). Coups can also boost popular mobilization, encouraging more actors to participate in anti-government demands (Brancati, 2014).…”