De novo mutations play a prominent role in neurodevelopmental diseases including autism, schizophrenia, and intellectual disability. Many de novo mutations are dominant and so severe that the afflicted individuals do not reproduce, so the mutations are not passed into the general population. For multimeric proteins, such severity may result from a dominant-negative effect where mutant subunits assemble with WT to produce channels with adverse properties. Here we study the de novo variant G375R heterozygous with the WT allele for the large conductance voltage- and Ca2+-activated potassium (BK) channel, Slo1. This variant has been reported to produce devastating neurodevelopmental disorders in three unrelated children. If mutant and WT subunits assemble randomly to form tetrameric BK channels, then ~6% of the assembled channels would be wild type (WT), ~88% would be heteromeric incorporating from 1-3 mutant subunits per channel, and ~6% would be homomeric mutant channels consisting of four mutant subunits. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed the biophysical properties of single BK channels in the ensemble of channels expressed following a 1:1 injection of mutant and WT cRNA into oocytes. We found ~3% were WT channels, ~85% were heteromeric channels, and ~12% were homomeric mutant channels. All of the heteromeric channels as well as the homomeric mutant channels displayed toxic properties, indicating a dominant negative effect of the mutant subunits. The toxic channels were open at inappropriate negative voltages, even in the absence of Ca2+, which would lead to altered cellular function and decreased neuronal excitability.