Iterative, nonreducing polyketide
synthases (NR-PKSs) are multidomain
enzymes responsible for the construction of the core architecture
of aromatic polyketide natural products in fungi. Engineering these
enzymes for the production of non-native metabolites has been a long-standing
goal. We conducted a systematic survey of in vitro “domain swapped” NR-PKSs using an enzyme deconstruction
approach. The NR-PKSs were dissected into mono- to multidomain fragments
and recombined as noncognate pairs in vitro, reconstituting
enzymatic activity. The enzymes used in this study produce aromatic
polyketides that are representative of the four main chemical features
set by the individual NR-PKS: starter unit selection, chain-length
control, cyclization register control, and product release mechanism.
We found that boundary conditions limit successful chemistry, which
are dependent on a set of underlying enzymatic mechanisms. Crucial
for successful redirection of catalysis, the rate of productive chemistry
must outpace the rate of spontaneous derailment and thioesterase-mediated
editing. Additionally, all of the domains in a noncognate system must
interact efficiently if chemical redirection is to proceed. These
observations refine and further substantiate current understanding
of the mechanisms governing NR-PKS catalysis.