COVID-19 and Its Psychological Impacts on Healthcare Staff – A Multi-Centric Comparative Cross-Sectional Study

Abstract

Background Since the first case of coronavirus disease-19 (COVID-19) in Pakistan was reported in February 2020, the medical and paramedical staff has been working on the frontlines to deal with this disease. They have been facing significant strain and stress due to the pandemic, affecting their social, mental, and personal life. The purpose of this study is to investigate the psychological effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, etiology, personal coping mechanisms, and the strategies that are being adopted to reduce stress by the healthcare workers (HCWs) working in COVID-19 dedicated wards (group 2) and compare it with staff working in other departments but not in COVID-19 wards amid this pandemic (group 1) in various hospitals of Lahore, Pakistan. Methods The comparative cross-sectional study was designed which included doctors, nurses, and allied health professionals from various hospitals of Lahore, Pakistan. A questionnaire was designed which consisted of five sections, and 51 questions. A Chi-square test was used to compare the responses between these two groups. Results The study questionnaire was submitted by 200 participants, 100 responses for each group (see the Appendix). In group 1, HCWs not working in COVID-19 dedicated floors were afraid of getting infected, transmitting the infection to their families and concerned about using personal protective equipment (PPE) improperly. They reported a lack of concentration and tense muscles. The coping mechanisms of this group were exercise, strict precautions at work, and social distancing measures. While HCWs serving in COVID-19 dedicated wards were concerned and afraid of putting their families at risk by working in the high-risk environment; the major stresses in this group were: lack of knowledge about proper strategies for treatment, they faced insecurity due to physical and verbal violence by caretakers of COVID-19 patients, and lack of concentration. The coping mechanism was the support of their families and taking strict precautions, with self-isolation if required, to avoid any disease transmission to their families. The proposed strategies to be implemented included teaching skills for self-rescue as well as the implementation of policies at the administrative level to reduce working hours and frequent shift rotation. Conclusion The COVID-19 outbreak posed a great deal of mental stress among HCWs working on the COVID-19 floor as well as those serving in other departments of the hospital. The HCWs from group 1 were most afraid of getting infected and putting family members at risk, experienced tense muscles and lack of concentration, coped their stress by exercise and being more vigilant, and suggested the strategies of teaching skills for self-rescue and better community awareness. While the staff from the second group were most afraid of being the source of infection and violence from the caretakers of patients, experienced tense muscles, used family support, and strict isolation measures as coping mechanisms and suggested the strategies of selfrescue ...

Prevalence, forms, risk factors, and impact of violence towards healthcare workers during the Covid – 19 pandemic in Malawi

“…However, in our study, the prevalence of overall violence was much higher. This is consistent with other studies globally that show an increase in violence toward healthcare workers since the beginning of the Covid -19 pandemic (5,7,8,15,16,17). In the pre-pandemic study, Banda et al reported the prevalence of physical assault and verbal abuse at 9% and 66% respectively (7).…”

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental health of hospital staff: An umbrella review of 44 meta-analyses

“…Our study failed to confirm that female hospital staff had a statistically significant higher prevalence of anxiety, depression, and sleep problems. Other studies have shown that the female sex is a risk factor for developing severe depression and anxiety among hospital staff ( Qiu et al, 2020 ; Shahid et al, 2020 ; Varghese et al, 2021 ). Female participants from the general population are also more likely to report higher levels of anxiety and depression than their male counterparts before ( Cavanagh et al, 2017 ) and after the COVID-19 pandemic ( Qiu et al, 2020 ).…”

Predictors of the Occupational Burnout of Healthcare Workers in Poland during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…Human resources constitute a key element of the safe functioning of healthcare institutions [ 1 ]. In the times of the COVID-19 pandemic, working in the healthcare sector has become a source of stress for a large number of workforce, especially physicians, nurses and paramedics who work ‘at the frontline’ [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ]. Many aspects of this pandemic have caused moral distress, and unexpected challenges to the ethical values of health professionals, including complex human rights issues in many settings.…”