COVID-19’s Impact on the 2020-2021 Resident Match: A Survey of Otolaryngology Program Directors

Abstract

Objective: To determine the impact coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) will have on the 2020-2021 otolaryngology (OTO-HNS) resident application cycle. Methods: A cross-sectional survey targeting OTO-HNS program directors (PD) was created and disseminated via email to PDs on May 28th 2020. Descriptive analyses of the 19-question survey was performed, and free text responses for certain suitable questions were thematically categorized into groups determined to be relevant during analysis. Results: Twenty-nine of 123 solicited PDs (23.6%) completed the survey. Nineteen (65.5%) respondents indicated they would not host away rotations (AR) in 2020, and 9 (31.0%) reported that they would consider away rotators without home programs. Regarding the historical importance of AR, 21 (72.4%) PDs stated they were either “extremely” or “very” important in evaluating candidates. Sixteen (55.2%) PDs stated that virtual interviews would impact their ability to properly gauge candidates and 12 (41.4%) were unsure. Eight PDs (27.6%) stated their evaluation of candidates will likely change, with a shift toward an increased reliance on letters of recommendation, research involvement, and clerkship grades. The large majority of PDs—25 (86.2%)—were not worried that the COVID-19 pandemic would affect the abilities of new interns beginning in 2021. Conclusion: Virtual interviews and engagement activities will mostly supplant sub-Is and AR for the 2020-2021 OTO-HNS application cycle. Surveyed PDs largely believe these will be insufficient in providing a comprehensive assessment of candidates, and will similarly limit applicants’ ability to gauge residency programs. Criteria utilized to evaluate students is expected to change.

Staying Close to Home: The Effects of COVID-19 on the Plastic Surgery Residency Match

“…A previous study of surgery program directors argued that letters of recommendation were more critical during a virtual process for evaluating an applicant. 6 , 8 The results of this survey reinforced the importance of letters of recommendation within the virtual application cycle. This perspective underscores the significant disadvantage of prospective applicants who do not have an established home plastic surgery residency program.…”

Virtual Resident Mentorship Groups for Fourth Year Medical Students Applying into Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery

“…In a competitive surgical subspecialty like Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (OHNS), students and residency program directors alike often consider subinternships a critical part of the transition to residency process. 1,2 This is particularly true for students without a home OHNS program, where visiting subinternships may affect their ability to gain entrance to the specialty. 3 Along with learning about potential future colleagues, interaction with residents allows students to experience the daily practice and expectations of the next phase of their trainingan opportunity so valuable that it has been built into accreditation standards for medical schools.…”

Effects of COVID‐19 on Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Fellowship Training and Director Practices

“… 8 , 9 Such actions posed unique challenges to residency and fellowship programs regarding the educational and clinical training opportunities of trainees. 10 , 11 Surgical trainees have been disproportionately affected by the public health efforts to mitigate the epidemic, as they rely on operative experience to complete their training. 10 Even as operations resumed in later stages of the pandemic, some questioned the risk/reward aspects of allowing fellows/residents to assist in a procedure in which they were not required, given the desire to minimize exposure to workers and patients and utilization of personal protective equipment (PPE).…”