“…At the same time, considerable variation in response was observed for all three types of nutrients, which reflects earlier findings in literature. For P, most published estimates of response in soybean, common bean, cowpea and groundnut tend to be between 150 and 500 kg ha −1 ( Chekanai et al, 2018 , Giller et al, 1998 , Kaizzi et al, 2018 , Kaizzi et al, 2012 , Maman et al, 2017 , Ronner et al, 2016 , Serme et al, 2018 , Tarfa et al, 2017 , Ulzen et al, 2018 , Zingore et al, 2008 ) and can be considered consistent with the 250 kg ha −1 found in our study, although responses below 100 kg ha −1 ( Ikeogu and Nwofia, 2013 , Mabapa et al, 2010 , Serme et al, 2018 , Smithson et al, 1993 ) and above 500 kg ha −1 ( Kaizzi et al, 2018 , Kamara et al, 2007 , Moses et al, 2018 , Tarfa et al, 2017 ) have also been reported.…”