Cracking the box or stretching its walls? Exploiting institutional plasticity in Iranian creative advertising

Abstract

Through a nine-month ethnography in an advertising agency in Iran, a deeply conservative society, we explore the microprocesses through which actors search for and exploit areas of institutional plasticity toward incremental change. Given the infeasibility of more significant change in a highly institutionalized arrangement, actors in these settings are likely to seek out institutions characterized by the highest degree of plasticity. Yet, extant institutional research has not yet addressed the question of how they may go about doing so, which is what we seek to do in this paper. By studying how celebrity endorsement became more normative in the field of advertising despite initial resistance from Iranian government regulators, we make four contributions to institutional literature. First, we demonstrate how institutional plasticity can serve as an antecedent to incremental institutional change in highly institutionalized contexts. Second, we trace the source of institutional plasticity to a misalignment between institutional pillars. Third, we identify the tactics and strategies that challengers use in the process of sensing institutional plasticity and stretching institutional boundaries. Finally, we shed light on the use of material and discursive resources across different stages of negotiations over incremental movements in the boundaries of normativity within a highly institutionalized setting.

How the Malleability of Material Artefacts Contributes to Institutional Maintenance: The Guimard Metropolitan railway entrances, 1914–2000

“…For example, Micelotta and Washington (2013) highlight the role of repair work by Italian legal professionals to maintain the status quo of their profession. In parallel, adaptations for institutional maintenance have also been discussed at the institutional level through the concept of plasticity (Ghaffari, Svystunova, & Jarvis, 2021; Lok & De Rond, 2013). This refers to variations in the developmental pattern or behaviour of institutions according to different external conditions.…”

An ethnographic study of organizational performances in business services: Space, staging and materiality

“…Similar to Ghaffari et al (2021), Rennstam and Kärreman (2020) and Skovgaard-Smith et al (2020), who approach ethnographic analysis abductively, the analysis began as the ethnographer followed ‘ideas and hunches’ from the field (Hammersley and Atkinson, 1995: 205). The author noted the importance of the physical environment at SuperTech.…”

Role of gender in white-collar crime: an examination of the emancipation and focal concerns hypotheses

“…As argued by Ghaffari et al (2022, p. 1707), Iran is “a deeply conservative society.” Hoodfar and Sadr (2010, p. 885) discussed Islamic politics and women’s quest for gender equality in Iran:…”