A number of techniques have been developed to repair the aesthetic and functional defects in patients affected by facial paralysis. The choice of technique in the dynamic rehabilitation of the smile is influenced by factors such as the patient’s age, facial phenotype, time of evolution or the surgeon’s preferences, among others. When a nerve transfer or the neurotization of a muscle transplant are performed, the dilemma arises of selecting the ideal donor nerve. The hypoglossal and masseteric nerves are usually used for this type of procedure. Although the hypoglossal nerve can achieve effective facial movements, mass facial movements and synkinesis have also been described. Depending on the level of nerve coaptation, these side effects could be avoided to some extent. Moreover, the recovery of spontaneous facial smiling using the hypoglossal nerve is almost anecdotal. On the other hand, the masseteric nerve allows neurotization of the facial nerve without the use of nerve grafting, provides a high axonal load, faster recovery and, above all, a higher percentage of spontaneous smile, especially in women. Therefore, the masseteric nerve would be the donor nerve of choice in the rehabilitation of short-term facial paralysis.