Craniotomy Burr Hole Covers: A Comparative Study of Biomechanical, Radiological, and Aesthetic Outcomes Using 3 Different Plug Materials

Abstract

Burr holes in the cranial vault are usually made during trephination for craniotomy or drainage of chronic subdural hematomas. The resulting cranial defect might bring to unsatisfactory esthetic outcome. In the current study the authors report clinical data regarding a cohort of patients who were treated with 3 different types of burr hole covers; autologous bone dust from skull trephination, and 2 different types of cylindric plug made out of porous hydroxyapatite in order to evaluate medium and long-term esthetic and radiological outcomes. Twenty patients were consecutively enrolled in the study and in each patient all 3 types of materials were used to cover different holes. Clinical and radiological outcomes at 6 and 12 months, were analyzed for all 3 types of plugs in terms of thickness of the graft coaptation of margins, remodeling, fractures, mobilization, and contour irregularities. In all craniotomy holes filled with autologous bone dust the authors have observed partial or complete bone reabsorption at 1 year and in 60% of the cases a visible and palpable cranial vault contour irregularity was reported. Both types of bone substitutes gave satisfactory results, comparable to autologous bone dust at 6 months and superior at 12 months, especially in terms of thickness and esthetic appearance. Hydroxyapatite plugs have shown better esthetic and biomechanical results and higher patients’ satisfaction compared to autologous bone dust while not giving any additional complications.