Criminalizing solidarity: Search and rescue in a neo-colonial sea

Abstract

Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) rescued over 110,000 people in the Central Mediterranean Sea between 2015 and 2017. From 2017, EU member states and agencies increasingly criminalized these organizations, accusing them of ‘colluding with smugglers’ and acting as a pull factor. In this climate, as Italy, Malta and the EU increased cooperation with Libya to stop people from taking to the seas, many suspended their operations. This article explores the search and rescue efforts of NGOs in the Central Mediterranean Sea between 2014 and 2018. We examine the criminalization of this NGO activity and argue that it is made possible through an oscillating neo-colonial imagination of the sea as mare nostrum and mare nullius, our sea and nobody’s sea, respectively. We build on the work of other scholars who have pointed to the activation of the Mediterranean as ‘empty’ in response to migration flows, erasing the historical connections of colonialism, empire, trade, and exchange in the Mediterranean as well as the contemporary legal geographies that govern the space. Here, we go further to develop the idea of a neo-colonial sea, which is alternately imagined as empty and ‘European’. We explore how NGOs disrupt these depictions, as well as the disappearing figures of the migrant and refugee amidst the contestations between NGOs and states.

The entangled geographies of responsibility: Contested policy narratives of migration governance along the Balkan Route

“…4. There is by now an extensive literature examining the criminalization of solidarity in the wider Mediterranean space -see, among others, Carrera et al (2019), Cusumano (2019), Cuttitta (2018), Heller and Pezzani (2018), Mainwaring andDeBono (2021), Tazzioli (2018). 5.…”

We don't remember the O‐Platz protest camp for the sake of it. Collective memories and visibility of migrant activism in Berlin

“…In March 2018, the newly appointed German federal government introduced new restrictive asylum and migration policies (Perolini, 2021). Moreover, in June 2018, the newly elected Italian government relinquished the leading role that Italy had assumed until then to coordinate search and rescue operations in the central Mediterranean Sea, and adopted a new policy refusing disembarkation of rescue vessels, in particular, those operated by NGOs (Mainwaring & De Bono, 2021).…”

Humanitarianism and its Alternative Models in Migration Crises: the Case of Poland

“…4 Moreover, charitable acts performed in this context are not only humanitarian in their nature. They express a political stance contrary to the government, which often leads to the marginalisation and criminalisation of those providing help, for example NGO workers and volunteers carrying out rescue operations in the Mediterranean (Mainwaring, DeBono, 2021).…”