Criteria of “Effectiveness” and Related Aspects in Adaptive Reuse Projects of Heritage Buildings

Abstract

Adaptive reuse (AR) of heritage buildings is a complex process due to the involvement of many actions and actors, which influence the results of the projects. The effectiveness of AR projects can be described by various criteria. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the criteria of effectiveness in AR projects with the final scope to guide and improve the AR process. A review of the jury reports of two highly prestigious awards in the Netherlands (NRP Golden Phoenix award) and Europe (Europa Nostra) has been conducted. In total, the reports of 48 cases have been reviewed. The five criteria mentioned in the regulations of the NRP award have been used to categorize the aspects mentioned in the jury reports of both awards. These criteria are: “social value creation”, “sublimation (both architectural and cultural aspects)”, “environmental sustainability”, “economic value creation”, and “innovation”. This review reveals that “social value creation” and “sublimation” are among the most highlighted criteria that the juries considered for the effectiveness of AR projects. Often aspects mentioned for these criteria overlap partially with those aspects mentioned in the criterion of “economic value creation”. This indicates that enhancement of the qualities of heritage buildings and their surroundings and improvement of the social values and the resulting positive economic effects are strictly interrelated. The overview of the criteria of effectiveness, as defined in this work, will serve as a basis for the investigation of the tools and methods which can be used in the AR process to achieve these criteria.

Urban buildings sustainable adaptive reuse into tourism accommodation establishments: a SOAR analysis

“…It is primarily associated with historic or iconic building or site restoration, structure or façade preservation, as well as interior renovation towards adapting an existing establishment to a new use [2,3]. Although adaptive reuse can sometimes generate controversy due to the nuanced distinctions among renovation, façadism, and other closely related architectural and construction practices [4], it is generally seen as a suitable compromise between (historic) preservation and demolition [5,6]. After all, such projects address the three pillars of sustainable development, namely the environment, economy, and society, well-serving the principles of the circular economy model [7,8].…”

Analysis of Rural Heritage House Facades as the Initial Step Towards Their Adaptive Reuse and Renovation: A Case Study of Sixteen Houses in Mazandaran Province, Iran

“…When it comes to reusing or renovating existing built environments and, more specifically, heritage buildings, several studies have proposed different process models for the whole process [11] to not only preserve the values of heritage buildings but also to ensure effective results [12]. In this paper, the process model of Arfa et al (2022) is used as the backbone of the research, highlighting the necessity of the "analysis" of the existing built environment instead of starting from a blank page [8,9]. Figure 1 shows the model.…”

“…There are several international studies focused on the villages of this province, and they concentrate on the plan's grammar rather than the details of the facades [6,7]. The aim of this study is to study and analyze the exterior facade details of these historic buildings and document them as a necessary step [8][9][10], before initiating their reuse to a new function or renovation to continue their lives as houses.…”

Determination of Conservation–Reuse Parameters for Industrial Heritage Sustainability and a Decision-Making Model Proposal

“…This method is developed as a combination of different methods such as the complex adaptive system (CAS), analytic hierarchy process (AHP), the structural equation model (SEM), the fuzzy evaluation, the judgment matrix, and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. Arfa et al [16] aimed to determine the parameters that enable choosing the ideal project. Parameters are provided from NRP Gulden Fenix Rapporten and Europa Nostra Awards specifications.…”