Critical Appraisal and Hazards of Surface Electromyography Data Acquisition in Sport and Exercise

Abstract

The aim of this critical appraisal and hazards of surface electromyography (SEMG) is to enhance the data acquisition quality in voluntary but complex movements, sport and exercise in particular. The methodological and technical registration strategies deal with telemetry and online data acquisition, the placement of the detection electrodes and the choice of the most adequate normalization mode.Findings compared with the literature suggest detection quality differences between registration methods and between water and air data acquisition allowing for output differences up to 30% between registration methods and up to 25% decrease in water, considering identical measures in air and in water. Various hazards deal with erroneous choices of muscles or electrode placement and the continuous confusion created by static normalization for dynamic motion. Peak dynamic intensities ranged from 111% (in archery) to 283% (in giant slalom) of a static 100% reference. In addition, the linear relationship between integrated EMG (IEMG) as a reference for muscle intensity and muscle force is not likely to exist in dynamic conditions since it is muscle -joint angle -and fatigue dependent. Contrary to expectations, the literature shows 30% of non linear relations in isometric conditions also. SEMG in sport and exercise is highly variable and different from clinical (e.g. neurological) EMG. Choices of electrodes, registration methods, muscles, joint angles and normalization techniques may lead to confusing and erroneous or incomparable results.

Manifestations of muscle fatigue in baseball pitchers: a systematic review

“…Surface EMG is the recording of electrical signals transmitted from the brain to the neuromuscular junction, resulting in the contraction of the muscle, and the production of a force at the end effector (Dowling, 1997; De Luca, 1997). While consideration must be made surrounding factors of movement, fatigue, skin impedance, and a variety of other physiological and environmental factors related to the interpretation of EMG, the use of surface EMG in sports is a non-invasive method of predicting internal forces as a result of human movement (Clarys et al, 2010). There are challenges with inferring the results from EMG during pitching, particularly with changes in kinematics.…”

The lower body muscle activation of intermediate to experienced kayakers when navigating white water

“…The research team were keen to assess EMG signals from hip flexors and extensors, though this was very limited due to the design of thigh rests within boats. This reinforced the practicality of having full access to all surface muscles when undertaking performance in a closed-boat environment (Clarys, Scafoglieri, Tresignie, Reilly, & Roy, 2010;Turker & Sozen, 2013). In addition, a comfortable but secure place for the EMG data logger to be positioned was difficult when wearing full personal protective equipment (PPE), notably when a spray deck was worn.…”

Muscle Activity Onset Prior to Landing in Patients after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

“…Furthermore, average values for activity onset and the corresponding SD or SE of the following muscles were extracted: medial hamstrings, lateral hamstrings (biceps femoris), vastus lateralis, vastus medialis, gastrocnemius medialis and gastrocnemius lateralis. The EMG results used for the medial hamstrings were gathered either from the semitendinosus muscle [ 26 – 28 ] or the semimembranosus muscle [ 29 ], given their similar function and the high degree of cross-talk in their surface EMG signals [ 30 ]. For those studies focusing on walking, only results obtained during horizontal walking and at self-selected speed were used.…”