Critical Geography in Preschool: Evidence of Early Childhood Civic Action and Ideas about Justice

Abstract

Background U.S. preschool children from Latinx immigrant and Black communities often experience schooling rooted in compliance and overdiscipline. In these contexts, schools do not recognize the rich lived experiences of Children of Color as suitable for civic learning. This article explores how, when schools value young Children of Color as capable and their work as important, classrooms become sites of children's daily embodied civic action. Purpose Our study sought to better understand how children conceptualize and enact their ideas about community and to document the kinds of civic action present in early childhood classrooms. Applying theoretical tools of critical geography, we specifically analyzed how children used space and materials to enact their vision of a just community. Participants Three classrooms—an inclusion classroom, a bilingual classroom, and an English-only general education classroom—located within a Head Start center in South Texas participated in this study. The campus is roughly 65% Latinx, 33% Black, and 2% White, serving 3-, 4-, and 5-year-old children. Research Design This study used a multisited, comparative ethnographic methodology. Multisited ethnography allows researchers to locate patterns and contextual differences that impact people's lived experiences. Initially, researchers conducted ethnographic observations through field notes, photographs, and short videos documenting children's action on behalf of or with the classroom community. Next, we used video-cued ethnographic methods, filming for three days in each classroom and editing the footage into a 20-minute film. We showed that film to teachers, families, and children in focus groups. Analysis occurred in multiple phases, during which we refined codes through individual, partner, participant, and team-level work. Findings Children used physical space and materials to assert community membership and to strengthen community ties. They adapted space and classroom materials to include other community members in shared activities. Finally, children advocated for space for their own purposes. Conclusions When teachers and administrators approach the classroom as a civic space where children representing racial, linguistic, and ability diversity can access embodied experiences with civic action, children can use their space to act on behalf of the community. Rather than offering lesson-based social-emotional learning, schools can reflect on how children might build a just, caring community through authentic embodied experiences that include having some control over space and materials. Doing so may allow a shift toward class environments that support shared endeavors and opportunities for children to care for community members.

Seeking the masculine with the feminine: P-6 pre-service teachers’ views on teaching about the 2020 US presidential election

“…Young children are capable of difficult political conversations when provided the opportunity (Payne and Journell, 2019; Payne et al, 2020; Zakai, 2019). Future studies may consider strategies for engaging early childhood and elementary preservice teachers in these conversations.…”

Caring in the Context of Discipline Reform: A Framework for Researchers and Policymakers

“…From this perspective, teachers and other school staff are not assumed to be the "knowers" of good behavior, innocence, and culpability (Freidus, 2020). Indeed, from a young age, children develop ideas about justice and civic action (Payne et al, 2020), and co-construct school discipline in practice (Vavrus & Cole, 2002).…”

Taking Early Childhood Education and Young Children’s Learning Experiences Seriously

“…Yoon’s (2021) “Stars, Rainbows, and Michael Myers: The Carnivalesque Intersection of Play and Horror in Kindergarteners’ (Trade)marking and (Copy)writing” details how young children disrupt power hierarchies and regulatory boundaries in their play. Payne et al’s (2020) “Critical Geography in Preschool: Evidence of Early Childhood Civic Action and Ideas about Justice” details observations and interviews with young children as they worked to use classroom space and materials to create justice for one another and their families. “African American Head Start Teachers’ Approaches to Police Play in the Era of Black Lives Matter” by Henward et al (2021) centers Black teachers’ ways of thinking about young children engaging with real events in their lives and those they are witnessing in the larger society.…”