Abstract. Remnants of the Caribbean Large Igneous Plateau (C-LIP) are found as thicker
than normal oceanic crust in the Caribbean Sea that formed during rapid
pulses of magmatic activity at ∼91–88 and ∼76 Ma. Strong geochemical evidence supports the hypothesis that the C-LIP
formed due to melting of the plume head of the Galápagos hotspot, which
interacted with the Farallon (Proto-Caribbean) plate in the eastern
Pacific. Considering plate tectonics theory, it is expected that the
lithospheric portion of the plume-related material migrated within the
Proto-Caribbean plate in a north–north-eastward direction, developing the
present-day Caribbean plate. In this research, we used 3D lithospheric-scale,
data-integrative models of the current Caribbean plate setting to reveal, for
the first time, the presence of positive density anomalies in the uppermost
lithospheric mantle. These models are based on the integration of up-to-date
geophysical datasets from the Earth's surface down to 200 km depth,
which are validated using high-resolution free-air gravity measurements. Based
on the gravity residuals (modelled minus observed gravity), we derive density
heterogeneities both in the crystalline crust and the uppermost oceanic mantle
(<50 km). Our results reveal the presence of two positive mantle
density anomalies beneath the Colombian and the Venezuelan basins, interpreted
as the preserved fossil plume conduits associated with the C-LIP
formation. Such mantle bodies have never been identified before, but a
positive density trend is also indicated by S-wave tomography, at least down
to 75 km depth. The interpreted plume conduits spatially correlate
with the thinner crustal regions present in both basins; therefore, we
propose a modification to the commonly accepted tectonic model of the
Caribbean, suggesting that the thinner domains correspond to the centres of
uplift due to the inflow of the hot, buoyant plume head. Finally, using six
different kinematic models, we test the hypothesis that the C-LIP originated
above the Galápagos hotspot; however, misfits of up to ∼3000 km are found between the present-day hotspot location and the
mantle anomalies, reconstructed back to 90 Ma. Therefore, we shed
light on possible sources of error responsible for this offset and discuss two
possible interpretations: (1) the Galápagos hotspot migrated (∼1200–3000 km) westward while the Caribbean plate moved to the north,
or (2) the C-LIP was formed by a different plume, which – if considered fixed
– would be nowadays located below the South American continent.