“…4, Table 4), we selected mean annual temperature (BIO1), temperature annual range (BIO7), mean temperature of wettest quarter (BIO8), annual precipitation Fig. 9, samples "Lieberose Crest", "Lieberose Slope", "Lieberose Base", "Nizzana Crest", "Nizzana Slope", "Nizzana Base" Concostrina- Zubiri et al (2013) Data from Table 4, samples "EX", "LI", "MI", "HI" Chamizo et al (2011) Data from Table 2, samples "El Cautivo P", "El Cautivo IC", "El Cautivo C", "El Cautivo L", "Las Amoladeras C", "Las Amoladeras L", "Las Amoladeras M" Beraldi-Campesi et al (2009) Data from Table 1, samples "CP1", "CP2", "CP3", "SD8, "SD9", "SD18" Spröte et al (2010) Data from Figures 7 and 10, samples "H1", "H2", "H3", "L1", "L2", "L3" (L -Lugteich, H -Huehnerwasser) Kuske et al (2012) Data from Table 1 and Figure 1b, samples "Arches untrampled", "Arches trampled", "ISKY-1 untrampled", "ISKY-1 trampled", "ISKY-2 untrampled", "ISKY-2 trampled" Herrick et al (2010) Data from Table 2, samples "H1", "H2", "H3", "L1", "L2", "L3" (L -Low, H -High) Muscha & Hild (2006) Location coordinates from Figure 1 using Google Earth, Textures from Table 1, Biomass and crust types from Figure 3, samples "BigTrails in", "PoisonSpider in", "Donlin in", "PowderRim in", "LanderAnt in", "WorlandCattle in", "SandCreek in", "RankinBasin in", "RedWash2 in" Dougill & Thomas (2004) Location coordinates from Figure 1 using Google Earth, data from Table 1, samples "Makoba", "Molopo", "Omaheke rangelands", "Omaheke ranch", "Berry Bush" Kidron et al (2010) Data from Table 2, samples "Early succession", "Late succession" Thomas et al (2002) Location coordinates from Figure 1 using Google Earth, data from Table 1 and Table 3, samples Kalahari "Sands Bio 1", "Kalahari Sands Bio 2", "Ironstone Ridge Bio 1", "Ironstone Ridge Bio 2", "Ironstone Ridge Bio 3", "Ironstone Colluvium Bio 1", "Ironstone Colluvium Bio 2", "Ironstone Colluvium Bio 3", "Valley Alluvium Bio 1", "Valley Alluvium Bio 2", "Valley Alluvium Bio 3", "Calcrete Colluvium Bio 1", "Calcrete Colluvium Bio 2", "Calcrete Colluvium Bio 3", "Calcrete Ridge Bio 1", "Calcrete Ridge Bio 2", "Calcrete Ridge Bio 3" Abed et al (2010) Location coordinates from Figure 1 using Google Earth, data from Tables 1 and …”