Biomimetic synthesis of aragonite with various templates in vitro is an important way to understand the biomineralization process and synthesize nacre-like materials. Herein, we used the siphon sheath from the bivalve Lutraria sieboldii as the substrate for the formation of calcium carbonate. We found that the inner layer of the sheath, which is composed of approximately 40% protein and 60% β-chitin, induced the formation of nearly pure aragonite by the transformation of amorphous calcium carbonate (ACC). More surprisingly, unique starfruit-shaped aragonite aggregates were observed on the substrate and were constructed from many adhered, oriented aragonite tablets. We consider that the acid-rich protein from the inner layer of the siphon sheath triggers the formation of ACC, and the swollen β-chitin regulates the transformation of ACC into aragonite by lattice matching and stereochemical recognition. The various surface adhesion energies of the crystal, the change in growth rates on different crystallographic facets, and the hexagonal features of the aragonite tablets led to the formation of starfruit-shaped aragonite aggregates.