The global electrophilicity index
(GEI) has been further explored as a general and base-free metric
for Lewis acidity. A number of computational methods, including post-Hartree–Fock,
density functional theory, and time-dependent density functional theory,
have been explored. In this fashion, we sought the method most applicable
to a range of different Lewis acids with differing structural and
electronic features, including boron trihalides, silicon tetrahalides,
fluoroaryl boranes, and group 15 pentahalides. The most accurate and
computationally efficient approach was found to use the energies of
the orbitals from a geometry optimization at the B3LYP/def2-TZVP level
of theory. In addition, the GEI is shown to act as an effective acidity
metric that is complementary to the fluoride ion affinity. The GEI
also proved to be a better gauge of Lewis acidity for softer bases,
as confirmed by comparison to the iodide ion affinity of the group
15 pentahalides.