Superconducting samples with a starting composition Cu0.5TlxBa2Ca3Cu4O12 (x = 1–0.35) were prepared in Au tubes from oxides by using different heating rates. The optimum heating rate was 0.11 °C min−1 applied between 860 and 880 °C. These samples show the highest content of 1234 phase and the lowest of Ba–Cu–O phases as well as the highest critical temperatures. The highest values were Tc = 119.2 K and Tc0 = 115.1 K. All samples show Jc values around 6 × 105 A cm−2, at 60 K and 0.5 T. In the rest of the samples, heated by using lower or higher heating rates, a high concentration of 1223 and/or 1245 phases is detected. The content of the 1234 phase and of Ba(Ca,Tl)–Cu–O residual liquid phase, in the samples synthesized for the optimum heating rate, depends on the Tl content in the starting mixture. The influence of the oxygen content in the starting mixture on phase composition is not as strong as of Tl, but it has a major role in establishing the superconducting behaviour of the 1234 grains. Some arguments that suggest the dependence of the transport properties of the non-superconducting matrix on oxygen content will be discussed. In our technological arrangement the determined optimum heating rate can be applied to the synthesis of other single-layered superconducting phases, e.g. 1212 phase from a Cu0.25Tl0.75Ba2CaCu2O8.115 starting composition.