Cult of the “I”

Abstract

Cult of the "I": Organizational symbolism and curricula in three Scandinavian iSchools with comparisons to three American. Journal of Documentation, 73(1): 48-74https://doi.org/10.1108/JD- 04-2016-0042 Access to the published version may require subscription. N.B. When citing this work, cite the original published paper. Permanent link to this version:http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:lnu:diva-59563 1 Cult of the "I" -Organizational symbolism and curricula in three Scandinavian iSchools with comparisons to three American. Structured Abstract:Purpose: The purpose of the research reported in this article is to analyze three Scandinavian iSchools in Denmark, Norway and Sweden with regard to their intentions of becoming iSchools and curriculum content in relation to these intentions. By doing so, a picture will be given of the international expansion of the iSchool concept in terms of organizational symbolism and practical educational content. In order to underline the approaches of the Scandinavian schools, comparisons are made to three American iSchools. Methodology:The study is framed through theory on organizational symbolism and through the intentions of the iSchool movement as formulated in its vision statements. Empirically, the study consists of two parts: (1) Close readings of three documents outlining the considerations of three Scandinavian LIS schools before applying for the iSchool status, and (2) statistical analysis of 427 syllabi from master level courses at three Scandinavian and three American iSchools.Findings: All three Scandinavian schools analyzed have recently become iSchools, and though some differences are visible it is hard to distinguish anything in their syllabi as carriers of what can be described as an iSchool identity. In considering iSchool identity, it is instead benefits on a symbolic level that are most prominent, such as branding, social visibility and the possible attraction of new student groups. The traditionally strong relation to national library sectors are emphazised as important to maintain, specifically in Norway and Sweden. Research limitations/implications:The study is made on iSchools in Denmark, Norway and Sweden with empirical comparison to three American schools. These comparisons face the challenge of meeting the educational system and programme structure of each individual country. Despite this, findings prove possible to use as ground for conclusions, although empirical generalizations concerning, for instance, other countries must be made with caution. Practical implications:This study highlights the practical challenges met in international expansion of the iSchool movement, both on a practical and symbolic level. Both the iSchool Caucus and individual schools considering becoming iSchools may use these findings as a point of reference in development and decision making. Originality/valueThis is an original piece of research from which the results may contribute to the international development of the iSchool movement, and extend the theoretical 2 unde...

Exploring the Evolution and Characteristics of the iSchool Movement in China

“…In contrast, some studies have addressed the side effects of this movement, such as dividing LIS community and isolating small LIS schools. 31 The aforementioned research has been either limited to theoretical discussions or focused on the characteristics or development of iSchools, and most of it has emphasized multidisciplinary and disciplinary data diversity and argued the undeniable connection between information and computer science. However, this research concentrates on the current landscape of Chinese iSchools and their emerging trends, an underresearched area.…”

Future LIS Education and Evolving Global Competency Requirements for the Digital Information Environment: An Epistemological Overview

“…Hence it is not surprising that LIS has a long history in the literature and there are continuing debates, around its disciplinary identity. This includes nomenclature arguments around 'Library Science', 'Librarianship', 'Library Studies', 'Information Science' or 'Information Studies', as well the more recent intense discourse around whether the iField or iSchool concept is a genuine paradigm shift from LIS or merely a symbolic one (Golub, Hansson, & Seldon, 2017;Chu, 2010;Bonnici, Subramaniam, & Burnett, 2009;Meziek, & Koenig, 2008;King, 2006).…”

Kompetencije knjižničara i informatologa: izazovi u vremenu društvenih i kulturnih promjena

“…na primjer, Audunson 2005, Audunson i Suva, 2016Tammaro 2007), drugi su pak zabrinuti da raznolikost ugrožava transparentnost i mobilnost studenata i nastavnika, a time predstavlja značajne probleme u postavljanju združenih programa te za suradnju među europskim visokoškolskim ustanovama općenito (usp. Aparac-Jelušić, 2007;Virkus, 2008;Johnson, 2013;Golub, Hansson i Selden, 2017). Prema Kajbergu (2007, str.…”