‘Culture’ as a discursive resource in newspaper articles from Le Monde about secularism: constructing ‘us’ through strategic oppositions with religion

Abstract

Building on research highlighting the complex webs of relations between secularism, culture, and religion, this study investigates how the concept of culture was utilized in discourses of laïcité from the newspaper le Monde. Articles (N = 76) published between 2011 and 2014 were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Results revealed the agency associated with the use of culture as it was strategicallyrather than systematicallyused in opposition to religion. Overall, cultureand the practices it definedtended to be represented as normal and invisible. On the other hand, religion tended to be constructed as a disruption to secularism and the corresponding cultural reality. The findings therefore suggested culture could be strategically used to validate and regulate specific practices as well as representations of the imagined community. This study complements previous research on discourses of secularism by drawing attention to the strategic divisions between culture and religion, and their implications. The findings draw attention to the construction of a secular imagined community because of the punctual and strategic use of culture and religion as proxies for 'us' and 'them'. Thus, the findings have practical implications as regards religious minorities' identification with and belonging to the nation.

From ‘intercultural-washing’ to meaningful intercultural education: Revisiting higher education practice

“…Especially problematic within the intercultural communication field is the solid or essentialist view of culture as an objectively describable system of cognitive and behavioral traits (most typically, territorially bound to the nation-state) that defines all the persons seen as belonging to the group. Intuitively appealing and offering the promise of the quick fix, the essentialist notions of culture have become and remain prominent in public discourses where different actors and media products tap into limited and restrictive understandings of 'cultural' identities and practices (see, e.g., Breidenbach & Nyíri, 2009;Sommier, 2018).…”

“How ELSE are you supposed to dress up like a Black Guy??”: negotiating accusations of Blackface in online newspaper comments

“…In the wake of the atrocities committed in the name of "race" during the Holocaust, that term has been dismissed from most European discourses but ended up being replaced by cultural and religious markers. National European identities have therefore become signifiers of White and Christianity (Essed and Trienekens 2008;Sommier 2018). Scholars have explained the logics of cultural racism as it operates in Europe, namely its connections to national imagined communities (Wren 2001) and the de-politicization of culture (Lentin 2004) that makes it possible to talk about "inter-cultural difference" rather than "inter-racial inequality" (Taguieff 1989, 77).…”