We analyze the electric field driven topological field effect transition on 2D-xene materials with the addition of momentum relaxation effects, in order to account for dephasing processes. The topological field effect transition between the quantum spin Hall phase and the quantum valley Hall phase is analyzed in detail using the Keldysh non-equilibrium Green’s function technique with the inclusion of momentum and phase relaxation, within the self-consistent Born approximation. Details of the transition with applied electric field are elucidated for the ON–OFF characteristics with emphasis on the transport properties along with the tomography of the current carrying edge states. We note that for moderate momentum relaxation, the current carrying quantum spin Hall edge states are still pristine and show moderate decay with propagation. To facilitate our analysis, we introduce two metrics in our calculations, the coherent transmission and the effective transmission. In elucidating the physics clearly, we show that the effective transmission, which is derived rigorously from the quantum mechanical current operator is indeed the right quantity to analyze topological stability against dephasing. Exploring further, we show that the insulating quantum valley Hall phase, as a result of dephasing carries band-tails which potentially activates parasitic OFF currents, thereby degrading the ON–OFF ratios. Our analysis sets the stage for realistic modeling of topological field effect devices for various applications, with the inclusion of scattering effects and analyzing their role in the optimization of the device performance.