Consider the random Cayley graph of a finite group G with respect to k generators chosen uniformly at random, with 1 ≪ log k ≪ log |G|; denote it G k . A conjecture of Aldous and Diaconis [1] asserts, for k ≫ log |G|, that the random walk on this graph exhibits cutoff. Further, the cutoff time should be a function only of k and |G|, to sub-leading order.This was verified for all Abelian groups in the '90s. We extend the conjecture to 1 ≪ k log |G|. We establish cutoff for all Abelian groups under the condition k − d(G) ≫ 1, where d(G) is the minimal size of a generating subset of G, which is almost optimal. The cutoff time is described (abstractly) in terms of the entropy of random walk on Z k . This abstract definition allows us to deduce that the cutoff time can be written as a function only of k andFor certain regimes of k, we find the limit profile of the convergence to equilibrium.Wilson [46] conjectured that Z d 2 gives rise to the slowest mixing time for G k amongst all groups of size at most 2 d . We give a partial answer, verifying the conjecture for nilpotent groups. This is obtained via a comparison result of independent interest between the mixing times of nilpotent G and a corresponding Abelian group G, namely the direct sum of the Abelian quotients in the lower central series of G. We use this to refine a celebrated result of Alon and Roichman [3]: we show for nilpotent G that G k is an expander provided k − d(G) log |G|. As another consequence, we establish cutoff for nilpotent groups with relatively small commutators, including high-dimensional special groups, such as Heisenberg groups.The aforementioned results all hold with high probability over the random Cayley graph G k .