Each plant species exhibited differential responses in terms of germination, seedling quality, leaf area, specific leaf area, root and shoot biomass, and percentage dry matter partitioning to the roots. Both the Indian mustard and carrot grew successfully in the biosolidsmine tailings substrate combinations while white lupin, sugar beet, cassava, and potato failed to grow in most of the substrate combinations. The most suitable biosolids-mine tailings combination was determined to be 75% biosolids -25% mine tailings, wherein most of the abovementioned growth parameters did not differ significantly from those of the plants grown in the control potting mix.