Purpose: Chemoresistance to 5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) is common during colorectal cancer (CRC) treatment. This study measured the chemotherapeutic effects of 5-FU, calcitriol, and/or metformin single/dual/triple regimens as complementary/alternative therapies. Methods: Ninety male mice were divided into: negative and positive (PC) controls, 5-FU, Cal, Met, 5-FU/Cal, 5-FU/Met, Cal/Met, and 5-FU/Cal/Met groups. Treatments lasted four weeks following CRC induction by azoxymethane. The therapeutic regimens were also applied in the SW480 and SW620 CRC cell lines. Results: The PC mice had abundant tumours, markedly elevated proliferation markers (survivin/CCND1) and PI3K/Akt/mTOR alongside reduced p21/PTEN/Cytochrome-C/Caspase-3 and apoptosis. All therapies reduced tumour numbers, with 5-FU/Cal/Met most prominent regimen. All protocols also decreased cell proliferation markers, inhibited PI3K/Akt/mTOR molecules, increased pro-apoptotic molecules with apoptosis index, and 5-FU/Cal/Met revealed the strongest anti-cancer effects. In vitro, all therapies equally induced G1-phase arrest in SW480 cells, whereas metformin-alone showed maximal SW620 cell numbers in G0/G1-phase. 5-FU/Met co-therapy also showed the highest apoptotic SW480 cell numbers (13%), whilst 5-FU/Cal/Met disclosed the lowest percentage (81%) of viable SW620 cells. Moreover, 5-FU/Cal/Met revealed maximal inhibitions of cell cycle inducers (CCND1/CCND3), cell survival (BCL2) and the PI3K/Akt/mTOR molecules alongside highest expression of cell cycle inhibitors (p21/p27), pro-apoptotic markers (BAX/Cytochrome-C/Caspase-3), and PTEN in both cell lines. Conclusions: Metformin monotherapy was superior to calcitriol, whereas the 5-FU/metformin protocol showed better anti-cancer effects relative to the other dual therapies. However, the 5-FU/Cal/Met approach displayed the best in vivo and in vitro tumoricidal effects related to cell cycle arrest and apoptosis, justifiably by enhanced modulations of the PI3K/PTEN/Akt/mTOR pathway.