Dashboards in Health Care Settings: Protocol for a Scoping Review

Abstract

Background Health care organizations increasingly depend on business intelligence tools, including “dashboards,” to capture, analyze, and present data on performance metrics. Ideally, dashboards allow users to quickly visualize actionable data to inform and optimize clinical and organizational performance. In reality, dashboards are typically embedded in complex health care organizations with massive data streams and end users with distinct needs. Thus, designing effective dashboards is a challenging task and theoretical underpinnings of health care dashboards are poorly characterized; even the concept of the dashboard remains ill-defined. Researchers, informaticists, clinical managers, and health care administrators will benefit from a clearer understanding of how dashboards have been developed, implemented, and evaluated, and how the design, end user, and context influence their uptake and effectiveness. Objective This scoping review first aims to survey the vast published literature of “dashboards” to describe where, why, and for whom they are used in health care settings, as well as how they are developed, implemented, and evaluated. Further, we will examine how dashboard design and content is informed by intended purpose and end users. Methods In July 2020, we searched MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library for peer-reviewed literature using a targeted strategy developed with a research librarian and retrieved 5188 results. Following deduplication, 3306 studies were screened in duplicate for title and abstract. Any abstracts mentioning a health care dashboard were retrieved in full text and are undergoing duplicate review for eligibility. Articles will be included for data extraction and analysis if they describe the development, implementation, or evaluation of a dashboard that was successfully used in routine workflow. Articles will be excluded if they were published before 2015, the full text is unavailable, they are in a non-English language, or they describe dashboards used for public health tracking, in settings where direct patient care is not provided, or in undergraduate medical education. Any discrepancies in eligibility determination will be adjudicated by a third reviewer. We chose to focus on articles published after 2015 and those that describe dashboards that were successfully used in routine practice to identify the most recent and relevant literature to support future dashboard development in the rapidly evolving field of health care informatics. Results All articles have undergone dual review for title and abstract, with a total of 2019 articles mentioning use of a health care dashboard retrieved in full text for further review. We are currently reviewing all full-text articles in duplicate. We aim to publish findings by mid-2022. Findings will be reported following guidance from the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist. Conclusions This scoping review will provide stakeholders with an overview of existing dashboard tools, highlighting the ways in which dashboards have been developed, implemented, and evaluated in different settings and for different end user groups, and identify potential research gaps. Findings will guide efforts to design and use dashboards in the health care sector more effectively. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID) DERR1-10.2196/34894

Protocol for developing a dashboard for interactive cohort analysis of oral health-related data

“…There is little empirical data demonstrating the advantages of using data dashboards for public health policy or decision making [ 3 , 18 , 29 ]. However, we suggest that there are a number of advantages to this type of data visualisation including; easy and interactive communication of descriptive statistics, data-driven hypothesis generation, faster dissemination of results, computational reproducibility, incremental (addition of further surveys) and accessible across multiple devices with potential for interactive learning.…”

“…One of the issues in health sciences research is the lack of training of researchers whose primary field is neither visual design or data analytics [ 10 , 29 ]. Some commentators have proposed that data literacy should be a core competence in dental curricula [ 2 ].…”

“…Developing an effective dashboard is only the first stage in communicating and disseminating research findings. Strategies to improve the uptake of dashboards and training for both researchers and end-users is essential to achieve any real beneficial outcomes [ 29 ]. However, data dashboards appear to be a promising means of sharing and collaborating and are an example of how literate programming and dynamic documents can contribute to research reproducibility.…”

Maintaining Implementation through Dynamic Adaptations (MIDAS): protocol for a cluster-randomized trial of implementation strategies to optimize and sustain use of evidence-based practices in Veteran Health Administration (VHA) patients

“…In VHA, advances in medical informatics in design and content have produced increasingly user-friendly, responsive, and actionable dashboards, which have helped to amplify the work of clinicians and academic detailing pharmacists in invaluable ways. Our team is currently conducting a scoping review that will provide deeper knowledge of factors affecting uptake and effectiveness of dashboards [ 50 ]. Well-designed dashboards promote data-driven care optimization for individual care and population health management.…”

Maintaining Implementation Through Dynamic Adaptations (MIDAS): Protocol for a Cluster-Randomized Trial of Implementation Strategies to Optimize and Sustain use of Evidence-based Practices Veteran Health Administration (VHA) Patients

“…In VHA, advances in medical informatics in design and content have produced increasingly user-friendly, responsive, and actionable dashboards, which have helped to amplify the work of clinicians and academic detailing pharmacists in invaluable ways. Our team is currently conducting a scoping review to a scoping review that will provide deeper knowledge of factors affecting uptake and effectiveness of dashboards (50). Well-designed dashboards promote data-driven care optimization for individual care and population health management.…”