Data Collection Mechanisms in Health and Wellness Apps: Review and Analysis

Abstract

Background There has been a steady rise in the availability of health wearables and built-in smartphone sensors that can be used to collect health data reliably and conveniently from end users. Given the feature overlaps and user tendency to use several apps, these are important factors impacting user experience. However, there is limited work on analyzing the data collection aspect of mobile health (mHealth) apps. Objective This study aims to analyze what data mHealth apps across different categories usually collect from end users and how these data are collected. This information is important to guide the development of a common data model from current widely adopted apps. This will also inform what built-in sensors and wearables, a comprehensive mHealth platform should support. Methods In our empirical investigation of mHealth apps, we identified app categories listed in a curated mHealth app library, which was then used to explore the Google Play Store for health and medical apps that were then filtered using our selection criteria. We downloaded these apps from a mirror site hosting Android apps and analyzed them using a script that we developed around the popular AndroGuard tool. We analyzed the use of Bluetooth peripherals and built-in sensors to understand how a given app collects health data. Results We retrieved 3251 apps meeting our criteria, and our analysis showed that 10.74% (349/3251) of these apps requested Bluetooth access. We found that 50.9% (259/509) of the Bluetooth service universally unique identifiers to be known in these apps, with the remainder being vendor specific. The most common health-related Bluetooth Low Energy services using known universally unique identifiers were Heart Rate, Glucose, and Body Composition. App permissions showed the most used device module or sensor to be the camera (669/3251, 20.57%), closely followed by location (598/3251, 18.39%), with the highest occurrence in the staying healthy app category. Conclusions We found that not many health apps used built-in sensors or peripherals for collecting health data. The small number of the apps using Bluetooth, with an even smaller number of apps using standard Bluetooth Low Energy services, indicates a wider use of proprietary algorithms and custom services, which restrict the device use. The use of standard profiles could open this ecosystem further and could provide end users more options for apps. The relatively small proportion of apps using built-in sensors along with a high reliance on manual data entry suggests the need for more research into using sensors for data collection in health and fitness apps, which may be more desirable and improve end user experience.

Prospective acceptability of digital phenotyping among pregnant and parenting people with opioid use disorder: A multisite qualitative study

“…Digital phenotyping, defined as the “moment-by-moment quantification of the individual-level human phenotype in situ using data from personal digital devices,” is a novel approach for understanding social and behavioral dimensions of health and disease that overcomes many of the challenges inherent in traditional data collection methods ( 18 ). Digital phenotyping uses a smartphone’s embedded sensors to unobtrusively and longitudinally capture real time objective data on users as they interact with and move through their natural environments ( 19 ). This approach has been widely used in behavioral medicine and psychiatry to identify clinical markers of disease risk, monitor symptoms and outcomes, and tailor treatments in mental health and addictive disorders, including substance use overdose and relapse prediction, detection, and intervention ( 20 , 21 ).…”

Health-Seeking Behavior and Its Associated Technology Use: Interview Study Among Community-Dwelling Older Adults

“…For instance, smartwatches and wristbands with various sensors can collect continuous biological, behavioral, and environmental data; deliver health interventions; and measure users' health outcomes [12]. Mobile apps can keep people connected with their families and friends, disseminate health information [13], store and share health and lifestyle data [14], manage chronic diseases [15], and manage medical appointments [16]. Self-test kits, such as Antigen Rapid Test Kits, allow people to obtain results swiftly and conveniently at any location and time [17].…”

Mobile Health Interventions: A Frontier for Mitigating the Global Burden of Cardiovascular Disease

“…A plethora of mHealth apps offer an array of features, encompassing workout tracking, medication reminders, and general health monitoring facilitated by smartphone sensors. Some applications also offer manual data entry options, including meal tracking and weight loss guidance [ 26 ]. These diverse functionalities empower individuals to tailor their cardiovascular health management in accordance with their specific requirements and preferences.…”