Data-driven research and healthcare: public trust, data governance and the NHS

Abstract

It is widely acknowledged that trust plays an important role for the acceptability of data sharing practices in research and healthcare, and for the adoption of new health technologies such as AI. Yet there is reported distrust in this domain. Although in the UK, the NHS is one of the most trusted public institutions, public trust does not appear to accompany its data sharing practices for research and innovation, specifically with the private sector, that have been introduced in recent years. In this paper, we examine the question of, what is it about sharing NHS data for research and innovation with for-profit companies that challenges public trust? To address this question, we draw from political theory to provide an account of public trust that helps better understand the relationship between the public and the NHS within a democratic context, as well as, the kind of obligations and expectations that govern this relationship. Then we examine whether the way in which the NHS is managing patient data and its collaboration with the private sector fit under this trust-based relationship. We argue that the datafication of healthcare and the broader ‘health and wealth’ agenda adopted by consecutive UK governments represent a major shift in the institutional character of the NHS, which brings into question the meaning of public good the NHS is expected to provide, challenging public trust. We conclude by suggesting that to address the problem of public trust, a theoretical and empirical examination of the benefits but also the costs associated with this shift needs to take place, as well as an open conversation at public level to determine what values should be promoted by a public institution like the NHS.

Economic Rationality in Decision-Making Regarding Newborn Screening: A Case Study in Quebec

“…Pressures by some groups, such as politicians, may be unavoidable, but their impact is limited to influencing the prioritization of health intervention evaluations. In any case, the emphasis on transparency and accountability throughout the evaluation process helps to maintain public trust in the HTA agency’s recommendations [ 34 , 35 , 36 ].…”

Do you need a blockchain in healthcare data sharing? A tertiary review

“…Transparency is not just a preference but a necessity in modern healthcare data management [69,70]. It fosters trust among stakeholders [63] and aids in compliance with regulatory standards [48].…”

Awareness, Attitudes and Willingness to Donate Biological Samples to a Biobank: A Survey of a Representative Sample of Polish Citizens

“…Respondents generally show great concern about the transfer of data from the public sector to the private sector due to low trust in the private sector. They fear that their information could be used to their detriment or in a manner inconsistent with their worldview [39,[50][51][52]. In 2010, both in the European Union and in Poland, physicians were given the most trust in terms of access to and oversight of data and samples stored in a biobank, 39% and 44%, respectively [32].…”