Data Performativity and Health: The Politics of Health Data Practices in Europe

Abstract

The European Commission produces the European Core Health Indicators (ECHI), a database containing different tools used to compare European Union (EU) countries and recommend policy changes. The ECHI feeds multiple reports and documents and finds its way into health policies. From this arises the main research question addressed in this paper: How is health in Europe influenced by ECHI data practices? Specifically, we look at how some health issues or populations are prioritized or dismissed, which ultimately shapes the meaning of and knowledge about health in Europe. To do so, we first develop the conceptual framework of “data performativity,” underlining how data practices shape their object/subject. We then explore the politics of evidence behind the ECHI health data that materialize into (1) the absence of some health issues and populations and (2) the hypervisibility of neoliberal health. In the end, we argue, the ECHI serves as a site of individual, collective, and political identity enunciation.

Using Higher-Order Constructs to Estimate Health-Disease Status: The Effect of Health System Performance and Sustainability

“…Although our research model uses the Spanish Ministry of Health, Social Service, and Equality data to verify our hypotheses, there remain some limitations. One limitation was due to the phenomenon of the invisibility of data [1] related to social care arrangements. In addition, our results are based solely on the Spanish territory, which opens up the possibility that the findings are specific only to this country.…”

“…Undoubtedly, this is reflected in improvements in the standard of the population's living. For its part, the population's health plays a fundamental role in its economic prosperity [1]. Health has a direct impact on the economy and economic growth [2].…”

“…The government will need tools to continuously evaluate and monitor the health system if its objective is for it to work properly [4,5]. Inadequate or inefficient health expenditure could slow down the economic growth of the entire country [1]. Having quality information when making decisions about health policies improves health, well-being, and patient satisfaction [5].…”

Health Policies Based on Patient Satisfaction: A Bibliometric Study

“…The European Commission created the European Core Health Indicators (ECHIs), which are health indicators of the European Union whose objective is to obtain comparable and reliable data to contribute to the production of policies. The data emanating from these indicators will give an indication of the appropriate health policies to apply [28].…”

Social Work Practice, Data, Time and Biopolitics: Looking at Short-Term RFPs in Contemporary Community Practice in a Canadian Context

“…This process is inherently from above and might mimic similar processes described in the preceding section around the construction of common assessments understood through datapoints and percentages as opposed to conversation and engagement. Blouin (2020) argues that large datasets perform objectivity in the assemblage of health data at the point at which datasets become evidence for doing something with it or when data becomes evidence. Specifically, he says that as databases convert large swaths of particular data points and present them as evidence for policy, programs and/or interventions, databases reflect both presence/absence and are implicated in the curated production of knowledge (p. 319).…”