Data quality in the Norwegian dairy herd recording system: Agreement between the national database and disease recording on farm

Abstract

The majority of herds in Norway participate in the national dairy herd recording system. For disease events, this involves transferring information registered on farm, using individual cow health cards (CHC), to the central cattle database (CCD). Before using data from such a database, validation with an aim of describing data quality should be performed, but is rarely done. In this study, diagnostic events from CHC and CCD from 74 dairy herds were compared. Events in 2008 from female cattle with minimum age of 1 yr were included (n=1,738). Discrepancies between the 2 data sources and assessment of data quality were evaluated using agreement between events on CHC and in CCD, calculating completeness and correctness for the CCD, and using a multivariable regression model for agreement (1/0). The agreement evaluation described the concordance between the 2 data sources, whereas the calculations of completeness and correctness depended on a reference data source assumed to be more reliable. Completeness of the CCD was defined as the proportion of diagnostic events on the CHC that was recorded therein. Correctness was defined as the proportion of the CCD events that was also recorded on the CHC, and with the same date and diagnostic code. The agreement was up to 87.5%, the majority of disagreement being caused by unreported events on the CHC (between 10 and 12% of all events). Completeness of the CCD was regarded as high, between 0.87 and 0.88, and correctness excellent, between 0.97 and 0.98. The multivariable regression model found 4 factors that increased the odds for diagnostic events being in agreement between CHC and CCD. These were the events occurring during the 305-d lactation period; the herd size being 75 cows or less; the event occurring during the spring, summer, or winter rather than autumn; and lastly, the diagnostic code for the disease event being preprinted on the CHC, involving a simple check mark as opposed to writing a 3-digit code. The model found a high degree of clustering within herd. In conclusion, disease data in the Norwegian national database for dairy cows are valid to use for epidemiologic research, having in particular an excellent correctness, but it is of concern that at least 10% of data are missing. The proportion of unreported data should be taken into consideration whenever data from this database are used. Reasons for discrepancies found are important to be aware of in any work aiming to improve data transfer from farm to central databases.

A cohort study of the effect of winter dysentery on herd-level milk production

“…However, the milk composition analysis data were available for a smaller subset of the study herds, so selection bias cannot be ruled out for this part of the analysis. The external validity was considered good for the Norwegian population of dairy herds, because 98% of all dairy herds were members of the Norwegian Dairy Herd Recording System in 2013 (Espetvedt et al, 2013), and the herds in the study area were not likely to differ significantly from Norwegian dairy herds across the country with respect to management systems and breeds. The results are likely also valid for other populations of smaller-scale dairy herds in temperate areas.…”

Herd level estimation of probability of disease freedom applied on the Norwegian control program for bovine respiratory syncytial virus and bovine coronavirus

“…In the current study, animal movements refer to movements where there is a change of owner, for which reporting is mandatory. Information about herd size was retrieved from the Norwegian dairy herd recording system (NDHRS) which in 2011 included 98% of Norwegian dairy herds (Espetvedt et al, 2013). BTM test results were provided by the largest producer organisation, TINE SA, and information on location of herds (coordinates, EUREF89/WGS 1984 UTM-32) was provided by the Norwegian Agriculture Agency.…”

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus and bovine coronavirus antibodies in bulk tank milk – risk factors and spatial analysis

“…During the study period, 98% of all dairy herds were members of the Norwegian Dairy Herd Recording System (NDHRS) which provides reliable records on herd characteristics, production parameters and disease occurrence (Espetvedt et al, 2013). The medical company distributing the only registered BCoV vaccine in Norway was contacted to get information regarding the number of units sold.…”