Data Sensemaking in Self-Tracking: Towards a New Generation of Self-Tracking Tools

Abstract

Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) researchers have been increasingly interested in investigating self-trackers' experience with self-tracking tools (STT) to get meaningful insights from their data. However, the literature lacks a coherent, integrated and dedicated source on designing tools that support self-trackers' sensemaking practices. To address this, we carried out a systematic literature review by synthesizing the findings of 91 articles published before 2021 in HCI literature. We identified four data sensemaking modes that self-trackers go through (i.e., self-calibration, data augmentation, data handling, and realization). We also identified four design implications for designing self-tracking tools that support self-trackers' data sensemaking practices (i.e., customized tracking experience, guided sensemaking, collaborative sensemaking, and learning sensemaking through self-experimentation). We provide a research agenda with nine directions for advancing HCI studies on data sensemaking practices. With these contributions, we created an analytical information source that could guide designers and researchers in understanding, studying, and designing for self-trackers' data sensemaking practices.

Tangible Data Visualization of Physical Activity for Children and Adolescents: A Qualitative Study of Temporal Transition of Experiences

“…Representing personal data makes the artifacts unique and personalized while recognizing that children's and adolescents' experiences with such artifacts are individual, subjective and relational (Bentvelzen et al, 2022;McCarthy & Wright, 2007). The personalized representation also enhances the customized tracking experience and sense-making of health data (Coşkun & Karahanoğlu, 2022). Therefore, we investigated how faded-weekly tangible visualizations might open a space for connecting, reflecting, interpreting, and learning about PA over time.…”

Supporting Self-Management in Women with Gestational Diabetes: The Effect of eMOM Mobile Application on Self-Discovery and Psychological Factors – A Mixed-Methods Study (Preprint)

“…Previous studies indicate that trial-and-error learning is prevalent among women with GDM [37][38][39][40][41][42]. In a recent study by Ibrahim et al [37], women diagnosed with GDM expressed a desire to have all their self-monitoring tools (such as phone apps, paper-based journals, spreadsheets) gathered in one place to aid in sense-making.…”

Testing a Consumer Wearables Program to Promote the Use of Positive Airway Pressure Therapy in Patients With Obstructive Sleep Apnea: Protocol for a Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial (Preprint)

“…[21] To increase the utility of the weekly report displaying nightly oxygen saturation data and patient reported outcomes on sleep quality, mood, and functioning, our study will include a check-in video visit at day 7 to orient the participant to the weekly report, which may promote participant engagement. [22] We will explore the effect of these sessions as well as participant experience with the intervention with semi-structured interviews conducted at the end of the research study.…”