Significant demand for lithium-ion batteries necessitates alternatives to Co-and Ni-based cathode materials. Cation-disordered materials using earth-abundant elements are being explored as promising candidates. In this paper, we demonstrate a coprecipitation synthetic approach that allows direct preparation of disordered rocksalt Li 2.4 Fe 1.0 Ti 1.0 O 4.7 (r-LFTO•C) and spinel structured hybrid Li 0.5 Fe 1.0 Ti 0.9 O 3.2 •C (s-LFTO•C) nanoparticles with a conformal conductive carbon coating. High-angle annular dark-field imaging coupled with electron energy loss spectroscopy mapping shows uniform Fe/Ti distribution with minor compositional variation among particles. Cation disorder was confirmed for both of the materials at an atomic level, with a short-range order more pronounced in r-LFTO•C. Operando X-ray absorption spectroscopy, ex situ hard X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, ex situ soft X-ray absorption spectroscopy, and ex situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction were used to investigate (de)lithiation in the bulk and at the surface. Structurally, the r-LFTO•C demonstrated reversible partial Fe center migration between octahedral and tetrahedral sites during (de)lithiation. The r-LFTO•C evidenced that the redox of O was coincident with iron redox during initial electrochemical cycling, while iron redox dominated later cycling. In contrast, s-LFTO•C electrochemistry involved iron redox throughout the cycling process. The findings rationalize the differences in the electrochemistry where r-LFTO•C shows higher initial capacity yet poorer capacity retention over a voltage window where O redox can be accessed, while the s-LFTO•C shows lower initial capacity yet improved capacity retention.