Decision Making for Nurse Staffing: Canadian Perspectives

Abstract

The effectiveness of methods for determining nurse staffing is unknown. Despite a great deal of interest in Canada, efforts conducted to date indicate that there is a lack of consensus on nurse staffing decision-making processes. This study explored nurse staffing decision-making processes, supports in place for nurses, nursing workload being experienced, and perceptions of nursing care and outcomes in Canada. Substantial information was provided from participants about the nurse staffing decision-making methods currently employed in Canada including frameworks for nurse staffing, nurse-to-patient ratios, workload measurement systems, and "gut" instinct. A number of key themes emerged from the study that can form the basis for policy and practice changes related to determining appropriate workload for nursing in Canada. These include the use of (a) staffing principles and frameworks, (b) nursing workload measurement systems, (c) nurse-to-patient ratios, and (d) the need for uptake of evidence related to nurse staffing.

Nurse staffing norm in Iran Hospitals: What features should be included for success?

“…in his study stated that experience level, knowledge, and task shifting are factors that are usually forgotten in designing an estimation model. [37]…”

Does EuroSCORE Predict intensity of Postoperative Care and Rehabilitation Parameters? A Prospective Evaluation

“…A point value is assigned to each indicator, whereby each point represents five minutes of nursing work. This "average" time methodology is based on the average amount of time required for the measuring on an average day, by an average nurse, for an average patient [16].…”

The Ontario Nursing Workload Demonstration Projects: Rethinking How We Measure, Cost and Plan the Work of Nurses

“…Nurses in the study appreciated providing their professional judgment to help estimate the nursing work requirements of patients. The priority and secondary indicators most important for decision-making included medical severity of patients, environmental complexity, nurse experience, patient turnover, nurse-to-patient ratio, cognitive status, infection control, nurse vacancy, predictability of patient types, nursing interventions, patient volumes, co-morbidities, patient introduction Over the years, numerous concerns have been raised regarding the validity and reliability of nursing workload data (Duffield et al 2006;McGillis Hall et al 2006;Hernandez and O'Brien-Pallas 1996;Hughes 1999). In response to these concerns, the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (MOHLTC) Health Results Team for Information Management and the Nursing Secretariat jointly commissioned a study in 2005 to assess the quality and value of nursing workload data collection.…”