Members of the Rickettsiella genus (Legionellales) are emerging as widespread bacteria associated with insects, arachnids, and crustaceans. While some Rickettsiella strains are highly virulent entomopathogens, others are maternally inherited endosymbionts that manipulate arthropod phenotypes, including the induction of defensive symbiosis and cytoplasmic incompatibility. However, the genomic diversity of Rickettsiella remains largely unexplored, and their genetic potential to induce complex phenotypes in arthropods is only partially understood. In this study, we sequenced five novel Rickettsiella genomes isolated from three tick species. Through comparative genomics, we observed that Rickettsiella members share similar metabolic capabilities, and collectively lack virulence genes from pathogenic Legionellales. Additional analysis of Rickettsiella genomes revealed significant variability in metabolic properties related to endosymbiosis. Specifically, their capacity to biosynthesize certain B vitamins and heme varies, suggesting a functional role of some Rickettsiella strains in the nutrition of their arthropod hosts. Some Rickettsiella genomes harbour homologs of Wolbachia cif genes, encoding for the effectors of cytoplasmic incompatibility, suggesting that Rickettsiella may use a similar molecular mechanism similar to manipulate the reproduction of their arthropod hosts. Phylogenomics further revealed that tick-borne Rickettsiella exhibit distinct evolutionary origins within the genus, indicating that Rickettsiella have undergone repeated horizontal transfers between ticks and other arthropods.