“…For consider a world in which the physical cause does not occur and which in other respects is as much like our world as possible. The over‐determination approach says that in such a world, the mental cause causes a physical event – namely that the principle of causal closure of the physical domain no longer holds.” [Kim, : 45]There have been numerous replies to Kim's arguments [Bennett, ; Block, ; Garrett, , ,; Marcus, ; Marras, ; Yablo, ] but I shall conduct the discussion around constitution theories of objects and property‐instances. Two arguments are found in this passage.…”