Red blood cell (RBC) transfusion therapy is essential for the survival of patients with hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia. A potentially fatal complication of transfusion is development of non-ABO alloantibodies to polymorphic RBC antigens, yet mechanisms of alloantibody formation remain unclear. Human and mouse RBCs acquire a “storage lesion” prior to transfusion, which in mice contributes to immunogenicity. We previously reported that mouse splenic dendritic cells (DCs) are required for RBC alloimmunization and are activated by sterile and leukoreduced mouse RBCs after storage. Yet how syngeneic RBCs activate innate immune pathways to induce DC activation is unknown. We now show that DC activation to transfused RBCs occurs regardless of alloantigen presence, suggesting that RBC damage induced during storage triggers innate immune receptors. We discovered an unexpected dependence of RBC alloimmunization on the Toll-like receptor (TLR) signaling adaptor molecule MyD88. TLRs are a class of pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) that regulate DC activation and signal through two adaptor molecules, MyD88 and TRIF. We show that the inflammatory cytokine response, DC activation, and the subsequent alloantibody response to transfused syngeneic RBCs require MyD88 but not TRIF, suggesting a restricted set of PRRs are responsible for sensing RBCs and triggering alloimmunization.