“…Evidence for glacier advances during the first millennium CE is widespread in the western Cordillera of North America outside of Alaska (Luckman, 2000;Reyes and Clague, 2004;Allen and Smith, 2007;Koch et al, 2007a;Jackson et al, 2008;Menounos et al, 2009;Clague et al, 2010;Samolczyk et al, 2010;Bowerman and Clark, 2011;Craig et al, 2011;Johnson and Smith, 2012;Maurer et al, 2012;Coulthard et al, 2012;Munro et al, 2012;Osborn et al, 2012;Craig and Smith, 2013;Hoffman and Smith, 2013;Mood and Smith, 2015), but glacier extent generally appears to have been smaller than during advances of the past millennium. Some glaciers were likely smaller before CE 500 than in the late 20 th century (Allen and Smith, 2007;Clague et al, 2010), even though other glaciers seem to have advanced during that same period (Jackson et al, 2008;Samolczyk et al, 2010;Maurer et al, 2012;Osborn et al, 2012;Hoffman and Smith, 2013).…”