Introduction: The aim was to determine the efficacy of an extraction policy designed to prevent osteoradionecrosis (ORN) in dentate areas of the jaw after intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT). A secondary aim was to establish whether our extraction policy risked unnecessary tooth extractions for areas designated to be not-at-risk of ORN. Methodology: Data were retrospectively collected from 100 oral cancer patients, including the fate of 1430 individual teeth, from diagnosis to follow-up. Results: Eight percent of IMRT-treated patients developed ORN; spontaneous cases (5) outnumbered those provoked by dental issues (3). All cases of ORN arose in regions irradiated with > 60 Gy, with the posterior mandible as preferred location, with nonspontaneous cases primarily due to progressive periodontitis. No correlation was found between the likelihood of extraction and cancer stage. Conclusions: A more robust extraction policy of teeth affected with periodontitis and pocket depths of 4-5 mm might be advocated in molar areas predicted to receive > 60 Gy. Unfortunately, our study's retrospective design precluded any detailed analyses of the underlying reasons for the 88 extractions that occurred at lower radiation dose thresholds; a more conservative approach may therefore be warranted for these low-risk areas.