Depressive symptoms and web user experience

Abstract

BackgroundDepression, as one of the most prevalent mental disorders, is expected to become a leading cause of disability. While evidence-based treatments are not always easily accessible, Internet-based information and self-help appears as a promising approach to improve the strained supply situation by avoiding barriers of traditional offline treatment. User experience in the domain of mental problems therefore emerges as an important research topic. The aim of our study is to investigate the impact of depressive symptoms on subjective and objective measures of web user experience.MethodIn this two-part online study (Ntotal = 721) we investigate the relationship between depressive symptoms of web users and basic website characteristics (i.e., content, subjective and objective usability, aesthetics). Participants completed search and memory tasks on different fully-functional websites. In addition, they were asked to evaluate the given websites with standardized measures and were screened for symptoms of depression using the PHQ-9. We used structural equation modeling (SEM) to determine whether depression severity affects users’ perception of and performance in using information websites.ResultsWe found significant associations between depressive symptoms and subjective user experience, specifically of website content, usability, and aesthetics, as well as an effect of content perception on the overall appraisal of a website in terms of the intention to visit it again. Small yet significant negative effects of depression severity on all named subjective website evaluations were revealed, leading to an indirect negative effect on the intention to revisit a website via impaired content perceptions. However, objective task performance was not influenced by depressiveness of users.DiscussionDepression emerges as capable of altering the subjective perception of a website to some extend with respect to the main features content, usability, and aesthetics. The user experience of a website is crucial, especially as it facilitates revisiting a website and thus might be relevant in avoiding drop-out in online interventions. Thus, the biased impression of persons affected by symptoms of depression and resulting needs of those users should be considered when designing and evaluating E-(Mental)-Health-platforms. The high prevalence of some mental disorders such as depression in the general population stresses the need for further investigations of the found effects.

Usability, Acceptability, and Satisfaction of a Wearable Activity Tracker in Older Adults: Observational Study in a Real-Life Context in Northern Portugal

“…Overall, our results align with a recent study investigating the impact of depressive symptoms on web user experience measures, indicating that mood may be a factor influencing technology usability [74]. Additionally, recent research investigating the relationship between user perceptions and user characteristics has shown that older adults demonstrate positive attitudes toward mobile technologies and report technologies' complexity.…”

User experience and acceptance of patients and healthy adults testing a personalized self-management app for depression: A non-randomized mixed-methods feasibility study

“…Especially the latter result reflects the role of users' expectations regarding an e-mental health app, as users with good computer skills might expect potential features with a higher level of technological sophistication than available in the app. Taking the fact into consideration that depressed patients in former studies seem to be less able to concentrate on complex website presentations 31 and to show an impaired perception of content, 30 our results highlight the suitability of the app for the specific target group. In our sample, patients showed less computer skills than the healthy controls which explain the negative association of depression scores and the respective level of acceptance towards the app.…”

European Portuguese Version of the User Satisfaction Evaluation Questionnaire (USEQ): Transcultural Adaptation and Validation Study

“…However, a higher depressive mood, as evaluated by the GDS, was negatively associated with the satisfaction perceived by participants using the device. Similarly, a recent study investigating the impact of depressive symptoms on measures of web user experience found a significant association between depressive symptoms and subjective user experience [ 63 ]. These results indicate that mood may be a factor influencing technology usability and may warrant further guidance and/or targeted approaches in the use of these technologies by specific populations.…”