For long-pulse operation of Wendelstein 7-X (W-7X) installation of an additional divertor component is being considered to protect the edges of the water-cooled divertor target plates. In this paper, the impact on plasma performance of such a protection element, the scraper element (SE), is analyzed using the state-of-the-art edge transport code EMC3-Eirene, combined with magnetohydrodynamic equilibrium magnetic fields calculated with the code package VMEC-Extender. From this numerical analysis, which is significantly more sophisticated than previous analyses of the SE performance [1] , the following conclusions can be drawn: First, the expected protection capability of the SE is confirmed. Second, the calculated heat load patterns are such that overload of other parts of the plasma-facing components may result from the planned scenario. Third, the SE will cause a significant reduction in the particle exhaust capability of the divertor. These results show that a decision to add SE is not straightforward. It is prudent to test its pros and cons by installation of a SE prototype as early as possible. That possibility is described in a recent paper [2].