The purpose of this study was to describe first-year underrepresented college students' sense of belonging following participation in the initial cohort of All Rise, a Career and Calling Circle (CCC). While Restorative Practices, like the circle process, have emerged in response to addressing student disciplinary issues on college campuses, little research exists as to how these approaches could be applied to proactively contribute to a sense of belonging. Specifically, this emerging intervention leverages the career interests of underrepresented (racially-minoritized, first-generation, and Pell-eligible) first-year students to create spaces that attempt to promote a sense of belonging. Understanding whether CCC contributed to the participants' sense of belonging can assist pre-professional and career advisors, faculty, and administrators in order to more fully support underrepresented pre-professional students. Interview data revealed themes related not only to making their professional goals more tangible and increasing confidence to pursue those goals, but also providing a safe space to connect with others. This suggests that CCC positively influenced students' sense of belonging both at the university and in their preprofessional journeys.