Designing for others: the roles of narrative and empathy in supporting girls’ engineering engagement

Abstract

Purpose Science museums provide a context for developing and testing engineering activities that support visitors in creating personally meaningful objects. This study aims to propose that narrative design elements in such engineering activities can foster empathy to support engineering engagement among girls ages 7–14. Design/methodology/approach Taking a constructionist approach to engineering design, the authors present results from an observational study (n = 202 girls) of engineering activities across three museums that were designed to foster girls’ engineering engagement by integrating narrative elements aimed to foster empathy in activities. Using quantitative counts from observation protocols, the authors conducted statistical analyses to explore relationships between narrative, engineering and empathy. Findings Linear regression demonstrated a statistically significant relationship between empathy and increased numbers of engineering practices within museum activities. Additionally, this led us to explore the impacts the potential narrative design elements may have on designing for empathy – multiple linear regressions found both narrative and empathy to be independently associated with engineering practices. Overall, the authors found that using narrative to design activities to elicit empathy resulted in girls demonstrating more engineering practices. Originality/value The authors offer design ideas to foster aspects of empathy, including user-centered design, perspective-taking, familiarity and desire to help.

Making an Influence: Sponsorship and Creolization on Social Media

“…The goal of this revisit research was to develop a deeper understanding of changes in adolescents' preferred text genres and channels of communication and to chart a movement from a print logic to a participatory, ludic, modular way of communicating through mediums such as photo, film, maker/craft, etc. (Peppler et al., 2022). In tracing the shifts in these young people's preferred communicative modes, one of the things I found was the widespread influence of the digital screen and its inherent social interactions and relationships, that is, their experience of meaning‐making was hyperactive, hyper‐social, and multisensory (McLean, 2020).…”

World‐Making Through a Feminist Abolitionist Lens in a STEAM Middle School Program

“…Efforts to expand understandings of girls' motivations for making and assess shifts in activity design are an ongoing topic of study within the literature on gender and making. Peppler et al (2021) found that designing for empathy and narrative-driven making made a difference in girls' participation in a museum makerspace. Similarly, Pinkard et al (2017) found that "interactive narratives motivated girls to continue with the challenging STEM activities and contrived a sense of authentic purpose to the work" (p. 506).…”

“…Key to this are opportunities to become conscious of one's positioning in the world through the systems (e.g., White supremacy, cisheteropatriarchy, and capitalism) that shape what is made natural and could be remade to imagine other social possibilities (Buenavista et al, 2021). Peppler et al 's (2021) and Pinkard et al 's (2017) work on purposeful making, and Erete et al 's (2021) principles amplify how makerspaces will replicate social inequities unless they specifically integrate sociopolitical understandings of teaching, learning, gender, and intersectionality across curriculum, instruction, and interactions (McKinney de Royston et al, 2021). The details and pedagogical "how" of this work is a central focus of our paper.…”

“…Learning in makerspaces is interdisciplinary in nature, engaging students through maker literacies that involve both traditional reading and writing, alongside learning key scientific principles (McLean & Rowsell, 2021). Yet despite growing popularity, makerspaces have also struggled to support the participation and engagement of girls, particularly girls from historically marginalized communities (Erete et al., 2021; Peppler et al., 2021), a pattern deeply at odds with the rhetoric of maker environments opening to more just futures. As such, there are growing efforts to research, design, and develop makerspaces that are able to nurture just and healthful relationships with each other and the world.…”

Personally Meaningful Design: Sound Making to Foster Engineering Practices with Artifacts from Home

“…The two groups were assigned by teachers at the school based on student interest and willingness to participate in the study. Additionally, the age range was selected as research suggests elementary and middle school is when learners begin to form conceptions about engineering and interest toward the field [46]. All participants visited the Junior Maker Space at least once and most had some engineering experiences prior to joining the workshop.…”