Sildenafil is highly effective for treating erectile dysfunction (ED). However, its use has been associated with serious adverse events including myocardial infarctions and strokes, and 130 verifiable plus 112 unverified deaths reported to the US Food and Drug Administration during the 8 months after sildenafil was introduced in the US, and 522 reported deaths during the 13.5 months after its introduction. Moreover, some events have occurred in men taking their first dose of the agent, suggesting that sildenafil, like some drugs that affect blood pressure, may provoke a first-dose reaction. This possibility warrants extra caution to be used when initiating treatment with sildenafil. Such caution is not currently provided by the current dosage guidelines that, for example, recommend the use of sildenafil 50 mg initially for most men between the ages of 18 and 65 years, despite wide differences in bodyweight, age, drug metabolism, health status and usage of other medications. It can be difficult to identify the patient who may be unusually sensitive to the effects of sildenafil. Exercise stress tests have been recommended, but serious adverse events have occurred in men with normal stress tests following the ingestion of sildenafil. Blood pressure monitoring following sildenafil administration will not prevent a serious adverse drug event already in progress. This article discusses the advantages and disadvantages of initiating treatment with a low test dose of sildenafil, performed at home or in the doctor's office. The advantages of this approach include: (i) identifying patients who are highly sensitive to the effects of sildenafil and who may need no higher dose; (ii) minimising adverse effects such as flushing and dizziness that often frighten patients and may affect adherence; (iii) avoidance of major adverse events; and (iv) reassuring patients with ED who remain wary about trying sildenafil therapy.