The effect of six heavy metals, namely, silver (Ag), lead (Pb), palladium (Pd), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), and chromium (Cr), on phosphorus (P) uptake by yeast was investigated by single-cell analysis using inductively coupled plasma time-of-flight mass spectrometry (SC-ICP-TOF-MS). It was found that the P content in cells with 1.55 g L–1 P feeding after P starvation was increased by ∼70% compared to control cells. Heavy metals at 10 ppm, except Cu, had a negative impact on P accumulation by cells. Pd reduced the P content by 26% in single cells compared to control cells. Metal uptake was strongest for Ag and Pd (0.7 × 10–12 L cell–1) and weakest for Cr (0.05 × 10–12 L cell–1). Exposure to Cr markedly reduced (−50%) Mg in cells and had the greatest impact on the intrinsic element composition. The SC-ICP-TOF-MS shows the diversity of elemental content in single cells: for example, the P content under standard conditions varied between 12.4 and 890 fg cell–1. This technique allows studying both the uptake of elements and sublethal effects on physiology at a single-cell level.