Determining menstrual phase in human biobehavioral research: A review with recommendations.

Abstract

Given the volume and importance of research focusing on menstrual phase, a review of the strategies being used to identify menstrual phase and recommendations that will promote methodological uniformity in the field is needed. We conducted a literature review via Ovid Medline and PsycINFO. Our goal was to review methods used to identify menstrual phase and subphases in biobehavioral research studies with women who had physiologically natural menstrual cycles. Therefore, we excluded articles that focused on any of the following: use of exogenous hormones, the postpartum period, menstrual-related problems (e.g. polycystic ovarian syndrome, endometriosis), and infertility/anovulation. We also excluded articles on either younger (<18 years old) or older (>45 years old) study samples. We initially identified a total of 1,809 articles. After our exclusionary criteria were applied, 146 articles remained, within which our review identified six different methods used to identify menstrual phase and subphases. The most common method used was self-report of onset of menses (145/146 articles) followed by urine luteinizing hormone testing (50/146 articles) and measurement of hormones (estradiol and/or progesterone) in blood samples (49/146 articles). Overall, we found a lack of consistency in the methodology used to determine menstrual phase and subphases. We provide several options to improve accuracy of phase identification, as well as to minimize costs and burden. Adoption of these recommendations will decrease misclassification within individual studies, facilitate cross-study comparisons and enhance the reproducibility of results.

The vaginal microbiome amplifies sex hormone‐associated cyclic changes in cervicovaginal inflammation and epithelial barrier disruption

“…27 We used a combination of serum hormone levels and days since LMP for phasing ( Figure S1 and Data S1). 27 We used a combination of serum hormone levels and days since LMP for phasing ( Figure S1 and Data S1).…”

Ovarian Hormones, Menstrual Cycle Phase, and Smoking: a Review with Recommendations for Future Studies

“…Following these mid-luteal phase peaks, both estradiol and progesterone levels decrease rapidly, and this part of the late luteal phase is commonly described as the premenstrual phase. There are several different approaches to determining menstrual cycle phase that are reviewed elsewhere [19]. For the purposes of this review, we refer to the follicular phase as the phase when estradiol levels are increasing and greater than progesterone; whereas, the luteal phase is the phase of the cycle when progesterone levels are increasing and greater than estradiol.…”

Twin models of environmental and genetic influences on pubertal development, salivary testosterone, and estradiol in adolescence

“…Consistent with this idea, previous research has found that genetic influences on hormone‐related eating phenotypes (eg emotional eating) shift across the menstrual cycle in late adolescent and adult women . Research using dense longitudinal measurement of hormones across the menstrual cycle, coupled with biological indicators of menstrual phase, is necessary to evaluate this topic further.…”